Commodores All-Americans
| Player | Year | Pos |
| Casey Hayward | 2011 | CB |
| D.J. Moore | 2008 | DB |
| Earl Bennett | 2006 | WR |
| Jamie Winborn | 1999 | LB |
| Jamie Duncan | 1997 | LB |
| Bill Marinangel | 1996 | P |
| Boo Mitchell | 1988 | WR |
| Chris Gaines | 1987 | LB |
| Ricky Anderson | 1984 | P |
| Leonard Coleman | 1983 | DB |
| Chuck Scott | 1983 | TE |
| Jim Arnold | 1982 | P |
| Allama Matthews | 1982 | TE |
| Preston Brown | 1979 | Back |
| Barry Burton | 1974 | TE |
| Bob Asher | 1969 | T |
| Chip Healy | 1968 | LB |
| George Diedrich | 1958 | G |
| Charley Horton | 1955 | RB |
| Bill Wade | 1951 | QB |
| Bob Werickle | 1951 | T |
| Bucky Curtis | 1950 | Receiver |
| Bob Gude | 1941 | C |
| Carl Hinkle | 1937 | C |
| Pete Gracey | 1932 | C |
| John Brown | 1929 | G |
| Dick Abernathy | 1928 | End |
| Bill Spears | 1927 | QB |
| Henry Wakefield | 1924 | End |
| Lynn Bomar | 1923 | End |
| Josh Cody | 1914, 1915, 1919 | T |
| Irby Curry | 1916 | Back |
| Lewis Hardage | 1912 | Back |
| Ray Morrison | 1911 | QB |
| W.E Metzer | 1910 | G |
| Owsley Manier | 1906 | Back |
Read more about this topic: Vanderbilt Commodores Football