Year-by-year
| Year | Record (W-L-D) | Regular Season Finish | Playoffs |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1967–68 | 6–7–2 | 4th, First Division, ASL | Did Not Qualify |
| 1968 | 6–5–1 | 4th, First Division, ASL | Did Not Qualify |
| 1969 | 12–3–5 | 2nd, Northern Division, ASL | Northern Division Playoff |
| 1970 | 9–9–6 | 1st, Northern Division | NASL Champions |
| 1971 | 13–5–6 | 1st, Northern Division | Semifinals |
| 1972 | 6–5–3 | 2nd, Northern Division | Semifinals |
| 1973 | 4–9–6 | 3rd, Northern Division | Did Not Qualify |
| 1974 | 8–10–2 | 3rd, Northern Division | Did Not Qualify |
| 1975 | 6–16 | 4th, Northern Division | Did Not Qualify |
| 1976 | 13–11 | 3rd, Northern Division, Atlantic Conference | First Round |
| 1977 | 11–15 | 3rd, Northern Division, Atlantic Conference | Division Championships |
| 1978 | 14–16 | 4th, Eastern Division, National Conference | Did Not Qualify |
| 1979 | 15–15 | 4th, Eastern Division, National Conference | Did Not Qualify |
| 1980 | 12–20 | 4th, Eastern Division, National Conference | Did Not Qualify |
Read more about this topic: Rochester Lancers