Hernandez V. Commissioner - Reasoning

Reasoning

Justice Thurgood Marshall began the majority opinion with a discussion of the legislative history of the "contribution or gift" limitation as described in IRC §170(c). When the tax bill was enacted in 1954, Congress distinguished between unrequited payments and payments made in return for goods and services. Specifically, the gift characterization was deemed to only apply "if there were no expectation of any quid pro quo..." In later decisions, the quid pro quo analysis was expanded to also apply to charitable contributions.

Hernandez and other taxpayers argued that the "quid pro quo" determination did not apply to this situation because the benefit they were receiving through the auditing and training was purely religious. The Court emphasized that IRC §170(c) clearly states that donations to religious organizations are only deductible if they are contributions or gifts, regardless of the expectations underlying the payments. The Court hesitated to broaden the scope of the deduction to any payments designed to achieve a religious benefit, since that could open the door to deductions such as those for parochial school tuition or payments to church-affiliated hospitals. The Court noted that refraining from characterizing the services provided by religious institutions prevented the government - the IRS and court system - from effectively monitoring the practices of a church.

Read more about this topic:  Hernandez V. Commissioner

Famous quotes containing the word reasoning:

    Listen to me, imbecile. If the Treasury is important, then human life is not. This is clear. All those who think like you ought to admit this reasoning and count their lives for nothing because they hold money for everything.
    Albert Camus (1913–1960)

    For this is one of the ancientest laws among them; that no man shall be blamed for reasoning in the maintenance of his own religion.
    Sir Thomas More (1478–1535)

    Accuracy is, in every case, advantageous to beauty, and just reasoning to delicate sentiment. In vain would we exalt the one by depreciating the other.
    David Hume (1711–1776)