Proof Complexity - Proof Size Comparison

Proof Size Comparison

A second question about proof complexity is whether a method is more efficient than another. Since the proof size depends on the formula, it is possible that one method can produce a short proof of a formula and only long proofs of another formula, while a second method can have exactly the opposite behavior. The assumptions of measuring the size of the proofs relative to the size of the formula and considering only the shortest proofs are also used in this context.

When comparing two proof methods, two outcomes are possible:

  1. for every proof of a formula produced using the first method, there is a proof of comparable size of the same formula produced by the second method;
  2. there exists a formula such that the first method can produce a short proof while all proofs obtained by the second method are consistently larger.

Several proofs of the second kind involve contradictory formulae expressing the negation of the pigeonhole principle, namely that pigeons can fit holes with no hole containing two or more pigeons.

Read more about this topic:  Proof Complexity

Famous quotes containing the words proof, size and/or comparison:

    “The insatiable thirst for everything which lies beyond, and which life reveals, is the most living proof of our immortality.”
    —Charles Baudelaire (1821–1867)

    “There are some persons we could not cut down to size without diminishing ourselves as well.”
    —Jean Rostand (1894–1977)

    “Most parents aren’t even aware of how often they compare their children. . . . Comparisons carry the suggestion that specific conditions exist for parental love and acceptance. Thus, even when one child comes out on top in a comparison she is left feeling uneasy about the tenuousness of her position and the possibility of faring less well in the next comparison.”
    —Marianne E. Neifert (20th century)