Negative Strategies
The negative has several options for refuting the affirmative's plan that relate to the man on the cliff:
- The man is not in fact walking towards the cliff, but perhaps away from it. Or, he is not moving at all. (Inherency)
- Walking off the cliff will actually have positive consequences for the man (Harms)
- The affirmative plan will not be sufficient to push the man away from the cliff, and he will fall off anyway. (Solvency)
- The affirmative plan will push the man away from the cliff, but towards a greater peril (such as another, steeper cliff). (Disadvantages).
- Even if the man falls off the cliff, it doesn't matter (Significance)
Read more about this topic: Man On The Cliff
Famous quotes containing the words negative and/or strategies:
“The idealist’s programme of political or economic reform may be impracticable, absurd, demonstrably ridiculous; but it can never be successfully opposed merely by pointing out that this is the case. A negative opposition cannot be wholly effectual: there must be a competing idealism; something must be offered that is not only less objectionable but more desirable.”
—Charles Horton Cooley (1864–1929)
“By intervening in the Vietnamese struggle the United States was attempting to fit its global strategies into a world of hillocks and hamlets, to reduce its majestic concerns for the containment of communism and the security of the Free World to a dimension where governments rose and fell as a result of arguments between two colonels’ wives.”
—Frances Fitzgerald (b. 1940)