Grand Unified Theory - Proposed Theories

Proposed Theories

Several such theories have been proposed, but none is currently universally accepted. An even more ambitious theory that includes all fundamental forces, including gravitation, is termed a theory of everything. Some common mainstream GUT models are:

  • minimal left-right model — SU(3)C × SU(2)L × SU(2)R × U(1)B-L
  • Georgi–Glashow model — SU(5)
  • SO(10)
  • Flipped SU(5) — SU(5) × U(1)
  • Pati-Salam model — SU(4) × SU(2) × SU(2)
  • Flipped SO(10) — SO(10) × U(1)
  • Trinification — SU(3) × SU(3) × SU(3)
  • SU(6)
  • E6
  • 331 model
  • chiral color

Not quite GUTs:

  • Technicolor models
  • Little Higgs
  • Preons
  • String theory
  • M-theory
  • Loop quantum gravity
  • Causal dynamical triangulation theory

Note: These models refer to Lie algebras not to Lie groups. The Lie group could be /Z2, just to take a random example.

The most promising candidate is SO(10). (Minimal) SO(10) does not contain any exotic fermions (i.e. additional fermions besides the Standard Model fermions and the right-handed neutrino), and it unifies each generation into a single irreducible representation. A number of other GUT models are based upon subgroups of SO(10). They are the minimal left-right model, SU(5), flipped SU(5) and the Pati-Salam model. The GUT group E6 contains SO(10), but models based upon it are significantly more complicated. The primary reason for studying E6 models comes from E8 × E8 heterotic string theory.

GUT models generically predict the existence of topological defects such as monopoles, cosmic strings, domain walls, and others. But none have been observed. Their absence is known as the monopole problem in cosmology. Most GUT models also predict proton decay, although not the Pati-Salam model; current experiments still haven't detected proton decay. This experimental limit on the proton's lifetime pretty much rules out minimal SU(5).

  • Proton Decay. These graphics refer to the X bosons and Higgs bosons.
  • Dimension 6 proton decay mediated by the X boson in SU(5) GUT

  • Dimension 6 proton decay mediated by the X boson in flipped SU(5) GUT

  • Dimension 6 proton decay mediated by the triplet Higgs and the anti-triplet Higgs in SU(5) GUT

Some GUT theories like SU(5) and SO(10) suffer from what is called the doublet-triplet problem. These theories predict that for each electroweak Higgs doublet, there is a corresponding colored Higgs triplet field with a very small mass (many orders of magnitude smaller than the GUT scale here). In theory, unifying quarks with leptons, the Higgs doublet would also be unified with a Higgs triplet. Such triplets have not been observed. They would also cause extremely rapid proton decay (far below current experimental limits) and prevent the gauge coupling strengths from running together in the renormalization group.

Most GUT models require a threefold replication of the matter fields. As such, they do not explain why there are three generations of fermions. Most GUT models also fail to explain the little hierarchy between the fermion masses for different generations.

Read more about this topic:  Grand Unified Theory

Famous quotes containing the words proposed and/or theories:

    We have no one to blame for the Kennedys but ourselves. We took the Kennedys to heart of our own accord. And it is my opinion that we did it not because we respected them or thought what they proposed was good, but because they were pretty. We, the electorate, were smitten by this handsome, vivacious family.... We wanted to hug their golden tousled heads to our dumpy breasts.
    —P.J. (Patrick Jake)

    The wise man regulates his conduct by the theories both of religion and science. But he regards these theories not as statements of ultimate fact but as art-forms.
    —J.B.S. (John Burdon Sanderson)