| Year | Premiers | Runners-Up |
|---|---|---|
| 1997 | David Mitchell Swans | Courthouse Eagles |
| 1998 | Prime Magpies | David Mitchell Swans |
| 1999 | David Mitchell Swans | New England Nomads |
| 2000 | New England Nomads | Prime Magpies |
| 2001 | New England Nomads | David Mitchell Swans |
| 2002 | Tamworth Kangaroos | Tamworth Swans |
| 2003 | Tamworth Kangaroos | New England Nomads |
| 2004 | New England Nomads | Tamworth Kangaroos |
| 2005 | Muswellbrook | Tamworth Swans |
| 2006 | Tamworth Swans | New England Nomads |
| 2007 | Inverell | Tamworth Kangaroos |
| 2008 | Tamworth Kangaroos | Inverell |
| 2009 | Tamworth Swans | Inverell |
| 2010 | Inverell | Tamworth Kangaroos |
| 2011 | Tamworth Kangaroos | Inverell |
Read more about this topic: Tamworth Australian Football League