Symbolic Speech - O'Brien Test

O'Brien Test

While writing the majority opinion for United States v. O'Brien, Chief Justice Warren described a series of guidelines used to determine whether a law that restricts speech violates the First Amendment. These guidelines must remain neutral in relation to the subject of the speech at hand (i.e., a speech that criticizes government action and is believed to violate a law must be treated the same way as a speech under identical circumstance, but praises the government as opposed to criticizing.) The O'Brien test is not meant to be the absolute deciding factor in cases involving non-verbal speech, but an additional tool to invoke against prohibitions.
The O'Brien Test is thus: The law in question must

  • be within the constitutional power of the government to enact.
  • further an important or substantial government interest.
    • That interest must be unrelated to the suppression of speech (or "content neutral", as later cases have phrased it.)
    • Prohibit no more speech than is essential to further that interest.

Read more about this topic:  Symbolic Speech

Famous quotes containing the word test:

    It is commonly said ... that ridicule is the best test of truth; for that it will not stick where it is not just. I deny it. A truth learned in a certain light, and attacked in certain words, by men of wit and humour, may, and often doth, become ridiculous, at least so far, that the truth is only remembered and repeated for the sake of the ridicule.
    Philip Dormer Stanhope, 4th Earl Chesterfield (1694–1773)