Contentious Cases
One of her most notable judgments as a High Court judge was in the David Lange vs Joe Atkinson defamation case which directly affected politicians. The final outcome on appeal was to give the news media a stronger defence against defamation actions by politicians.
Elias recused herself from a civil appeal case brought by Lisa Cropp. Cropp races horses owned by the Chief Justice and her husband. The appeal concerned the legality of the procedure that resulted in a positive test for methamphetamine and loss of standing to practice as a jockey. Supreme Court (Blanchard, Tipping, McGrath, Anderson and Gault JJ) dismissed the appeal.
Read more about this topic: Sian Elias
Famous quotes containing the word cases:
“We noticed several other sandy tracts in our voyage; and the course of the Merrimack can be traced from the nearest mountain by its yellow sand-banks, though the river itself is for the most part invisible. Lawsuits, as we hear, have in some cases grown out of these causes. Railroads have been made through certain irritable districts, breaking their sod, and so have set the sand to blowing, till it has converted fertile farms into deserts, and the company has had to pay the damages.”
—Henry David Thoreau (1817–1862)