Picking A Scale Factor
An example above illustrated how certain scale factors can cause unnecessary precision loss. We will revisit this example to further explore the situation.
We're storing representations of real data in 8 bit unsigned fixed point fields with 4 integer bits and 4 fractional bits. This gives us a range of in decimal, or in hex. Our real world data is all integers and in the range in decimal. Note that there are only 161 unique values that we may want to store, so our 8 bit field should be plenty, since 8 bits can have 256 unique configurations.
In the example given above, we picked a scale factor of 11 so that all the numbers would be small enough to fit in the range. However, when we began scaling the following real world data:
154, 101, 54, 3, 0, 160We discovered that the precision of these fractions is going to be a problem. The following box illustrates this showing the original data, its scaled decimal values, and the binary equivalent of the scaled value.
154/11 = 14 = 1110.0 101/11 = 9.1818... = 1001.00101110... 54/11 = 4.9090... = 100.111010... 3/11 = 0.2727... = 0.010010... 0/11 = 0 = 0.0 160/11 = 14.5454... = 1110.10010...Notice how several of the binary fractions require more than the 4 fractional bits provided by our fixed point format. To fit them into our fields, we would simply truncate the remaining bits, giving us the following stored representations:
1110.0000 1001.0010 0100.1110 0000.0100 0000.0000 1110.1001Or in decimal:
14.0 9.125 4.875 0.25 0.0 14.5625And when we need to bring them back into the real world, we need to divide by our scale factor, 1/11, giving the following "real world" values:
154.0 100.375 53.625 2.75 0 160.1875Notice how they've changed? For one thing, they aren't all integers anymore, immediately indicating that an error was introduced in the storage, due to a poor choice of scaling factor.
Read more about this topic: Scale Factor (computer Science)
Famous quotes containing the words picking a, picking, scale and/or factor:
“Cripples, above all men, should be companionable, or, at least, refrain from picking a fellow-limper to pieces.”
—Herman Melville (1819–1891)
“Preschoolers think and talk in concrete, literal terms. When they hear a phrase such as “losing your temper,” they may wonder where the lost temper can be found. Other expressions they may hear in times of crisis—raising your voice, crying your eyes out, going to pieces, falling apart, picking on each other, you follow in your father’s footsteps—may be perplexing.”
—Ruth Formanek (20th century)
“It is in vain that we would circumscribe the power of one half of our race, and that half by far the most important and influential. If they exert it not for good, they will for evil; if they advance not knowledge, they will perpetuate ignorance. Let women stand where they may in the scale of improvement, their position decides that of the race.”
—Frances Wright (1795–1852)
“Children of the middle years do not do their learning unaffected by attendant feelings of interest, boredom, success, failure, chagrin, joy, humiliation, pleasure, distress and delight. They are whole children responding in a total way, and what they feel is a constant factor that can be constructive or destructive in any learning situation.”
—Dorothy H. Cohen (20th century)