Federal Court of Appeals Unanimously Rules in Favor of Robert MacLean in A Precedential Decision
After going 24 minutes into overtime of oral arguments on January 4, 2013, on April 26, 2013, a unanimous panel of three United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit Judges issued a precedential decision in favor of MacLean. The court ruled that MacLean's disclosure did not violate the law and he may have defenses under the Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 (WPA).
| “ |
We agree with Mr. MacLean that the does not “specifically prohibit” the disclosure at issue in this case. The ATSA’s plain language does not expressly prohibit employee disclosures, and only empowers the Agency to prescribe regulations prohibiting disclosure of “if the Secretary decides disclosing the information would . . . be detrimental to public safety.” 49 U.S.C. § 40119(b) (emphasis added). Thus, the ultimate source of prohibition of Mr. MacLean's disclosure is not a statute but a regulation, which the parties agree cannot be 'law' under the WPA. |
” |
For the TSA to sustain its termination of MacLean, it must now attempt to argue that he did not have "a reasonable belief" that there was potential danger. Experts believe it will be close to impossible for the TSA to make such an argument given that the TSA itself admitted that its plan was "a mistake" and cancelled it before every going into effect, and so many prominent leaders of Congress expressed outrage, such as Chuck Schumer, John Kerry, and Hillary Clinton.
Circuit Judge Evan Wallach wrote a separate opinion concurring with his two fellow circuit judges:
| “ |
Mr. MacLean presented substantial evidence that he was not motivated by personal gain but by the desire to protect the public. |
” |
Read more about this topic: Robert Mac Lean
Famous quotes containing the words favor, federal, rules, unanimously, appeals, court and/or decision:
“The favor of a drop of water should be repaid as an overflowing spring.”
—Chinese proverb.
“Newsmen believe that news is a tacitly acknowledged fourth branch of the federal system. This is why most news about government sounds as if it were federally mandated—serious, bulky and blandly worthwhile, like a high-fiber diet set in type.”
—P.J. (Patrick Jake)
“Serious sport has nothing to do with fair play. It is bound up with hatred, jealousy, boastfulness, disregard of all rules and sadistic pleasure in witnessing violence: in other words it is war minus the shooting.
”
—George Orwell (1903–1950)
“Under the dominion of an idea, which possesses the minds of multitudes, as civil freedom, or the religious sentiment, the power of persons are no longer subjects of calculation. A nation of men unanimously bent on freedom, or conquest, can easily confound the arithmetic of statists, and achieve extravagant actions, out of all proportion to their means; as, the Greeks, the Saracens, the Swiss, the Americans, and the French have done.”
—Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803–1882)
“It was not reason that besieged Troy; it was not reason that sent forth the Saracen from the desert to conquer the world; that inspired the crusades; that instituted the monastic orders; it was not reason that produced the Jesuits; above all, it was not reason that created the French Revolution. Man is only great when he acts from the passions; never irresistible but when he appeals to the imagination.”
—Benjamin Disraeli (1804–1881)
“If a walker is indeed an individualist there is nowhere he can’t go at dawn and not many places he can’t go at noon. But just as it demeans life to live alongside a great river you can no longer swim in or drink from, to be crowded into safer areas and hours takes much of the gloss off walking—one sport you shouldn’t have to reserve a time and a court for.”
—Edward Hoagland (b. 1932)
“The issue is privacy. Why is the decision by a woman to sleep with a man she has just met in a bar a private one, and the decision to sleep with the same man for $100 subject to criminal penalties?”
—Anna Quindlen (b. 1952)