Fallacy Regarding Formation of Point Bars
An enduring fallacy exists regarding the formation of point bars and oxbow lakes. The fallacy suggests they are formed by the deposition of a stream's suspended load as the velocity and energy of the stream decreases in the bend. This fallacy relies on the erroneous notion that the speed of the water is slowest on the inside of the bend (where the radius is smallest) and fastest on the outside of the bend (where the radius is greatest).
If it were true that, around a bend in a stream, the difference between the speed of the water near one bank and the other was sufficient to cause deposition of suspended solids on one bank but not the other, the deposition would occur near the concave bank rather than the convex bank because vortex flow is slowest where the radius of curvature is greatest. Any fluid, including water in a stream, can only flow around a bend in vortex flow.
All point bars typically have a gently sloping floor with shallow water. The shallow depth of the water, and the fact that it is an accumulation of the boundary layer, prevent the water from reaching fast speed over the point bar. It is probably this observation which led early geographers to believe the slowest part of the stream is where the radius is smallest.
In a slow-flowing stream or river, the difference in speed between one bank and the other is not sufficient to provide a credible explanation as to why all the deposition occurs on one bank, and none on the other. Similarly, the fallacy has no explanation as to why all the deposition occurs at a stream bend, and little or none occurs where the stream is following a straight course. (The speed of water in a stream does not slow just because the stream enters a bend.)
In a mature, meandering stream or river the water speed is slow, turbulence is low, and the water is not capable of holding coarse sand and gravel in suspension. In contrast, point bars comprise coarse sand, gravel, polished stones and other submerged objects. These materials have not been carried in suspension and then dropped on the point bar – they have been swept and rolled into place by the secondary flow that exists across the floor of every stream in the vicinity of a stream bend.
Read more about this topic: Point Bar
Famous quotes containing the words fallacy, formation, point and/or bars:
“I’m not afraid of facts, I welcome facts but a congeries of facts is not equivalent to an idea. This is the essential fallacy of the so-called “scientific” mind. People who mistake facts for ideas are incomplete thinkers; they are gossips.”
—Cynthia Ozick (b. 1928)
“Out of my discomforts, which were small enough, grew one thing for which I have all my life been grateful—the formation of fixed habits of work.”
—Elizabeth Stuart Phelps (1844–1911)
“For the poet the credo or doctrine is not the point of arrival but is, on the contrary, the point of departure for the metaphysical journey.”
—Joseph Brodsky (b. 1940)
“The last public hanging in the State took place in 1835 on Prince Hill.... On the fatal day, the victim, a man named Watkins, peering through the iron bars of his cell, and seeing the townfolk scurrying to the place of execution, is said to have remarked, ‘Why is everyone running? Nothing can happen until I get there.’”
—Administration for the State of Con, U.S. public relief program (1935-1943)