Research Support
The system has been supported by multiple studies, though some research has shown contradictory results.
The Florida Center for Reading Research reported in 2006 that it was unable to identify any empirical studies examining the efficacy of the approach specifically as described in Orton-Gillingham training materials. Thus there was no direct research evidence to determine its effectiveness, although there are a variety of studies of derivative methods that incorporate aspects of Orton-Gillingham in combination with other techniques.
An overview of all reported studies of Orton-Gillingham derivative methods, such as Alphabetic Phonics or Project Read, revealed only a dozen studies with inconsistent results and a variety of methodological flaws. Despite these conclusions, the article does provide a detailed overview of the available research, which viewed most favorably would show some evidence of benefit from classroom use of OG methods with first graders, and use in special education or resource room settings with older children with learning disabilities.
In July 2010, a US Department of Education agency reported that it could not find any studies meeting its evidence standards to support the efficacy of Orton-Gillingham based strategies.
One study found it was effective for students who were English Language Learners.
A longitudinal study found it more effective than the Wilson reading system, because unlike Wilson the Orton-Gillingham does not focus on a small subset of students., allows for flexibility of approach, and is understood better by students.
Another study noted gains in California Achievement Test scores when students used the system, as opposed to the Wilson Reading System.
Research has indicated the system is effective in remediating instruction for students with dyslexia.
Read more about this topic: Orton-Gillingham
Famous quotes containing the words research and/or support:
“Our science has become terrible, our research dangerous, our findings deadly. We physicists have to make peace with reality. Reality is not as strong as we are. We will ruin reality.”
—Friedrich Dürrenmatt (1921–1990)
“In erotic love, two people who were separate become one. In motherly love, two people who were one become separate. The mother must not only tolerate, she must wish and support the child’s separation.”
—Erich Fromm (20th century)