Year-by-year
| Year | Division | League | Reg. Season | Playoffs | U.S. Open Cup | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1928-29 | N/A | ESL | 2nd | No playoff | Champion | |
| 1929 | N/A | ESL | 2nd | No playoff | N/A | |
| 1956/57 | N/A | ASL | 1st | Champion (no playoff) | Finals | |
| 1957/58 | N/A | ASL | 1st | Champion (no playoff) | ? | |
| 1958/59 | N/A | ASL | 1st | Champion (no playoff) | Quarterfinals | |
| 1959/60 | N/A | ASL | 3rd | No playoff | ? | |
| 1960/61 | N/A | ASL | 3rd | No playoff | ? | |
| 1961/62 | N/A | ASL | 5th | No playoff | ? | |
| 1962/63 | N/A | ASL | 6th | No playoff | ? | |
| 1963/64 | N/A | ASL | 5th | No playoff | ? | |
| 2011/12 | US West | NJSL | 4th | No playoff | Did not enter | as Hakoah Bergen County |
Read more about this topic: New York Hakoah