Contestants
| Name | Occupation | Hometown | Result | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shirley King | Home Health Agency Owner | Henderson, Nevada | 1st Victim | Chicken Ranch |
| Andrew "Andy" Landan | Media Planner | Chicago, Illinois | 2nd Victim | Old Mustard Mill |
| Lindsey Labrum | Student | Las Vegas, Nevada | 3rd Victim | The Verdant Hothouses |
| Stacey Carmona | Bartender | Staten Island, New York | 4th Victim | The Marine Supply Warehouse |
| Brian Porvin | Medical Student | Fort Lauderdale, Florida | 5th Victim | Kingfisher Aquaculture |
| Kristen Kirchner | Mortgage Banker | Los Angeles, California | 6th Victim | Sunrise Junkyard |
| Katie Kloecker | Office Temporary Work | Erie, Pennsylvania | 7th Victim | Sunrise High School |
| Jeff Monroe | Model | Portland, Oregon | 8th Victim | DeBeck's Compound |
| Alan Frye | Delicatessen Owner | Knoxville, Tennessee | Runner-Up | Kovick's Boathouse |
| Ángel Juarbe, Jr. | Firefighter | Bronx, New York | Winner | Lambert's House |
Read more about this topic: Murder In Small Town X