I
- "I Am, I Said" by Neil Diamond
- "I And Love And You" by The Avett Brothers
- "I Can't Live Without My Radio" by LL Cool J
- "I Can't See New York" by Tori Amos
- "I Dreamt I Dwelt in Harlem" by Glenn Miller & his Orchestra
- "I Feel Safe In New York City" by AC/DC
- "I Found Lovin'" by Steve Walsh
- "I Gotcha Back" by GZA
- "I Guess The Lord Must Be In New York City" by Harry Nilsson (covered by Sinéad O'Connor)
- "I Happen to Like New York" by Cole Porter
- "I Heart NYC" by Sorcha Richardson
- "I Just Wanna Have Something to Do" by Ramones
- "I'll Take New York" by Tom Waits
- "I'll Take Us Home" by Matt and Kim
- "I'll Sink Manhattan" by They Might Be Giants
- "I Love Harlem" by Asher Roth and Jim Jones
- "I Love Livin' In The City" by Fun Lovin' Criminals
- "I Love Manhattan" by Michael Ress
- "I Love N.Y." by Lazyboy
- "I Love NYC" by Andrew W.K.
- "I Love New York" by Steve Karmen
- "I Love New York" by Metroplis
- "I Love New York/New York New York" by Glee
- "I Love New York" by Madonna
- "I Love New York" by Selfish Cunt
- "I Remember Brooklyn" by Tony Visconti
- "I Remember Harlem" by Roy Eldridge
- "I Run New York" by 50 Cent featuring Tony Yayo
- "I Used To Be A Brooklyn Dodger" by Dion
- "I Woke Up in a Car" by Something Corporate
- "Ich war noch niemals in New York" by Udo Jürgens
- "I'm a Knicks Fan" by Jesse Jaymes
- "I'm Going Back to New York City" by Somebody's Chyldren
- "I'm Gonna Be A Country Girl Again" by Buffy Sainte-Marie
- "I'm Waiting For The Man" by The Velvet Underground
- "I'm Real" by James Brown
- "Idiot Kings" by Soul Coughing
- "If You Were Here" by Unlovables
- "Illume" by Fleetwood Mac
- "In a New York Minute" by Ronnie McDowell
- "In A New York Minute" by Sanne Salomonsen and Chris Minh Doky
- "In Brooklyn" by Al Stewart
- "In the Cage" by Genesis
- "In the City" by Milton
- "In the Flesh" by Blondie
- "Incident on 57th Street" by Bruce Springsteen
- "International Love" By Pitbull ft. Chris Brown
- "The Incumbent" by Soul Coughing
- "Into the Fire" by Bruce Springsteen
- "It's a Long Way Suzy To New York City" by The Subsonics
- "It's That East Street Beat" by Chocolette
- "It's Tricky" by Run DMC
- "In The Evening" by Sheryl Lee Ralph
- "In the Mood Again" by Elvis Costello
- "Iron God Chamber" by Masta Killa (Brownsville,Bed-Stuy)
- "Isle of Manhattan" by Spacehog
- "It Rains In New York Too" by Pete Miser
- "It's Nice to go Trav'ling" by Sammy Cahn and Jimmy Van Heusen
- "It's Snowing In New York" by Madison
- "I've Got New York" by The 6ths
- "Is It Raining in New York City?" by Cashman & West
- "I Wouldn't Live in New York City (If They Gave Me the Whole Damn Town) by Buck Owens
Read more about this topic: List Of Songs About New York City