Justice Stewart's Dissent
Justice Potter Stewart dissented from the Court's judgment, joined by Justices Hugo L. Black and John Marshall Harlan. According to Justice Stewart, the test for whether a statute violates the equal protection clause is a simple one: legislation should be held invalid only if it rest on grounds wholly irrelevant to achieving the legislature's objectives. Thus, according to the precedent of Lassiter v. Northampton County Board of Elections,states may impose restrictions on voting so long as they are reasonably designed to promote intelligent use of the ballot. Justice Stewart observed that residency requirement are a permissible type of restriction under this standard, and asserted that the majority had not sufficiently explained why this case fell under a different standard.
Read more about this topic: Kramer V. Union Free School District No. 15
Famous quotes containing the words justice, stewart and/or dissent:
“Life is not a matter of place, things or comfort; rather, it concerns the basic human rights of family, country, justice and human dignity.”
—Imelda Marcos (b. 1929)
“Anthropologists have found that around the world whatever is considered “men’s work” is almost universally given higher status than “women’s work.” If in one culture it is men who build houses and women who make baskets, then that culture will see house-building as more important. In another culture, perhaps right next door, the reverse may be true, and basket- weaving will have higher social status than house-building.”
—Mary Stewart Van Leeuwen. Excerpted from, Gender Grace: Love, Work, and Parenting in a Changing World (1990)
“Though dissenters seem to question everything in sight, they are actually bundles of dusty answers and never conceived a new question. What offends us most in the literature of dissent is the lack of hesitation and wonder.”
—Eric Hoffer (1902–1983)