Comparative Perspective
There are two points of view about where Itelmen belongs genetically. According to the first hypothesis, Itelmen and other Chukotko-Kamchatkan languages are derived from one proto-language; the sharp differences of Itelmen, noticed at all levels, are explained by the intense influence of other languages; it is suggested that Itelmen absorbed a different non-Chukotko-Kamchatkan language (V. G. Bogoraz, V. I. Jochelson, P. Y. Skorik). According to the second theory, Itelmen is not related to other Chukotko-Kamchatkan languages; common elements are seen as the effects of convergent evolution (D. Wort, A. P. Volodin, A. S. Asinovsky); thus, there is a basis to consider Itelmen genetically isolated, contrasted with the group of languages Chukotko-Koryak definitely related to Chukotko-Kamchatkan languages. There is also no genetic link between Itelmen and the language of the Ainu (the Southern neighbors of the Itelmen).
Initial comparisons of the Itelmen lexicon to Chukotko-Koryak in terms of the basic lexical stock show that instances of lexical commonality of Itelmen and Chukotko-Koryak languages make up approximately one third, with two thirds of the lexicons sharply distinct. The interpretation of these data are preliminary due to the incompleteness of Chukotko-Kamchatkan comparative phonetics.
Read more about this topic: Itelmen Language
Famous quotes containing the words comparative and/or perspective:
“The hill farmer ... always seems to make out somehow with his corn patch, his few vegetables, his rifle, and fishing rod. This self-contained economy creates in the hillman a comparative disinterest in the world’s affairs, along with a disdain of lowland ways. “I don’t go to question the good Lord in his wisdom,” runs the phrasing attributed to a typical mountaineer, “but I jest cain’t see why He put valleys in between the hills.””
—Administration in the State of Arka, U.S. public relief program (1935-1943)
“The fact that illness is associated with the poor—who are, from the perspective of the privileged, aliens in one’s midst—reinforces the association of illness with the foreign: with an exotic, often primitive place.”
—Susan Sontag (b. 1933)