1999-2000
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Geoff Sarjeant | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Claudio Scremin | London Knights | |
| Defence | Rob Stewart | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Kevin Riehl | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Rob Kenny | London Knights |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Brian Greer | Bracknell Bees | |
| Defence | Shayne McCosh | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Neal Martin | London Knights | |
| Forward | Teeder Wynne | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Mikko Koivunoro | Newcastle Riverkings | |
| Forward | Steve Thornton | Cardiff Devils |
Read more about this topic: ISL All-Star Team