Contestants
| Contestant Nickname | Real name | Eliminated |
|---|---|---|
| Tango | Patrick Hunter | 11bold !Winner |
| Chance | Kamal Givens | 10 !Runner-Up |
| Real | Ahmad Givens | 09 !Episode 9 |
| Whiteboy | Joshua Gallander | 08 !Episode 8 |
| 12 Pack | David Amerman | 07 !Episode 7 |
| Mr. Boston | Lee Marks | 06 !Episode 6 |
| Rico | Sandro Padrone | 05 !Episode 5 |
| Heat | Jason Rosell | 04 !Episode 4 |
| Onix | William Lash | 04 !Episode 4 |
| Bonez | Kevin Peters | 03 !Episode 3 |
| Pootie | Lamonty Council | 03 !Episode 3 (Quit) |
| T-Weed | Kevin Watson | 03 !Episode 3 |
| Romance | Ricky Perillo | 02 !Episode 2 |
| Token | Chase Irwin | 02 !Episode 2 |
| Trendz | Hashim Smith | 02 !Episode 2 |
| Ace | Darin Darnell | 01 !Episode 1 |
| Jersey | Bryant Covert | 01 !Episode 1 |
| T-Bone | Tyrone Ellis | 01 !Episode 1 |
| T-Money | Thomas Young | 01 !Episode 1 |
| Wood | Randy Richwood | 01 !Episode 1 |
- ^ Left in episode 3 due to mental distress.
Read more about this topic: I Love New York (season 1)