Use in Logical Frameworks
In the domain of logical frameworks, the term higher-order abstract syntax is usually used to refer to a specific representation that uses the binders of the meta-language to encode the binding structure of the object language.
For instance, the logical framework LF has a λ-construct, which has arrow (→) type. A first-order encoding of an object language construct let
would be (using Twelf syntax):
Here, exp
is the family of object language expressions. The family var
is the representation of variables (implemented perhaps as natural numbers, which is not shown); the constant v
witnesses the fact that variables are expressions. The constant let
is an expression that takes three arguments: an expression (that is being bound), a variable (that it is bound to) and another expression (that the variable is bound within).
The canonical HOAS representation of the same object language would be:
exp : type. let : exp -> (exp -> exp) -> exp.In this representation, object level variables do not appear explicitly. The constant let
takes an expression (that is being bound) and a meta-level function exp
→ exp
(the body of the let). This function is the higher-order part: an expression with a free variable is represented as an expression with holes that are filled in by the meta-level function when applied. As a concrete example, we would construct the object level expression
(assuming the natural constructors for numbers and addition) using the HOAS signature above as
let (plus 1 2) ( plus y 3)where e
is Twelf's syntax for the function .
This specific representation has advantages beyond the ones above: for one, by reusing the meta-level notion of binding, the encoding enjoys properties such as type-preserving substitution without the need to define/prove them. In this way using HOAS can drastically reduce the amount of boilerplate code having to do with binding in an encoding.
Higher-order abstract syntax is generally only applicable when object language variables can be understood as variables in the mathematical sense (that is, as stand-ins for arbitrary members of some domain). This is often, but not always, the case: for instance, there are no advantages to be gained from a HOAS encoding of dynamic scope as it appears in some dialects of Lisp because dynamically scoped variables do not act like mathematical variables.
Read more about this topic: Higher-order Abstract Syntax
Famous quotes containing the word logical:
“The logical English train a scholar as they train an engineer. Oxford is Greek factory, as Wilton mills weave carpet, and Sheffield grinds steel. They know the use of a tutor, as they know the use of a horse; and they draw the greatest amount of benefit from both. The reading men are kept by hard walking, hard riding, and measured eating and drinking, at the top of their condition, and two days before the examination, do not work but lounge, ride, or run, to be fresh on the college doomsday.”
—Ralph Waldo Emerson (18031882)