Victoria
- 1837 George Proctor - Bennington
- 1838 Claude George Thornton - Tewin
- 1839 Charles Benet Drake Gerard - Lamer Park
- 1840 Charles Snell Chauncy - Little Munden
- 1841 Robert William Gaussen - Brookmans
- 1842 George Gould Morgan - Brickendonbury
- 1843 Charles John Dimsdale - Essendon Place
- 1844 Frederick Cass - Little Grove
- 1845 Sir Henry Meux, 2nd Baronet - Theobalds Park
- 1846 Felix Calvert - Hunsdon House
- 1847 Humphrey Harper Burchell - Bushey Grange
- 1848 William Parker - Ware Park
- 1849 Abel Smith - Woodhall Park
- 1850 Fulke Southwell Greville - North Mimms Park
- 1851 William John Lysley - Mymms
- 1852 Wynn Ellis - Ponsbourne Park
- 1853 Sir Thomas Gage Sebright - Beechwood Park
- 1854 Robert Hanbury - Poles
- 1855 Nathaniel Hibbert - Munden
- 1856 William Joseph Myers - Porters
- 1857 William Reid - Codicote
- 1858 William Wilshere - Welwyn
- 1859 Martin Hadsley Gosselin - Ware
- 1860 James Bentley - Cheshunt
- 1861 William Jones Loyd - Langleybury
- 1862 John Hodgson - Gilston Park
- 1863 Samuel Richard Block - Barnet
- 1864 Sir Astley Paston Cooper - Gadesbridge
- 1865 Foster Alleyne McGeachey - Shenley Hill
- 1866 Henry Heyman Toulmin - Childwickbury
- 1867 Charles Booth - Stanstead Abbotts
- 1868 Robert Pryor - Watford
- 1869 Robert Smith - Goldings
- 1870 Unwin Unwin Heathcote - Shephallbury
- 1871 Charles Longman - Shendish
- 1872 Thomas Curtis - Great Berkhampstead
- 1873 HJ Smith - Bosanquet - Broxbournebury
- 1874 Sir John Gage Sebright - Beechwood
- 1875 James Sydney Walker - Hunsdonbury
- 1876 John Gwyn Jeffreys - Ware Priory
- 1877 David Carnegie - Watford
- 1878 Thomas Fowell Buxton - Ware
- 1879 Charles Butler - Hatfield
- 1880 Charles Cholmondely Hale - King’s Walden
- 1881 John Evans - Hemel Hempstead
- 1882 James William Carlile - Hertford
- 1883 Salisbury Baxendale - Ware
- 1884 Henry Hucks Gibbs - Watford
- 1885 Sir Astley Paston-Cooper - Gadebridge
- 1886 John Harry Eyres Parker - Ware Park
- 1887 Henry Wilson Demain-Saunders - Hertford
- 1888 William Bunce Greenfield - Flamsteadbury
- 1889 Joseph Grout Williams - Pendley Manor
- 1890 Hon Arthur Henry Holland-Hibbert - Munden
- 1891 Edmund Smith Hanbury - Poles, Ware
- 1892 Richard Benyon Croft - Ware
- 1893 Robert Barclay - Hoddesdon
- 1894 Edward Henry Loyd - Langleybury
- 1895 Edward Salvin Bowlby - Gilston Park
- 1896 Percival Bosanquet - Ponfield
- 1897 John Henry Buxton - Hunsdon Bury
- 1898 Charles Thomas Part - St Albans
- 1899 Frederick Henry Norman - Much Hadham
- 1900 Sir George Faudel-Phillips - Hertford
Read more about this topic: High Sheriff Of Hertfordshire