Ecosystem Restoration - Problems With Restoration

Problems With Restoration

Many people take the view that ecosystem restoration is impractical. One reason for this view is that restoration of ecosystems does not always work. There are many reasons for restoration failure. Hilderbrand et al. (2005) point out that many times uncertainty (about ecosystem functions, species relationships, and such) is not addressed, and that the time-scales set out for ‘complete’ restoration are unreasonably short. Other times an ecosystem may be so degraded that abandonment (allowing an injured ecosystem to recover on its own) may be the wisest option (Holl, 2006). Other negative impacts of ecosystem restoration can include the introduction of large predators, which may inspire doubts in people’s safety, and plants, some requiring disturbance regimes such as regular fires (MacDonald et al. 2002). High economic costs can also be a perceived as a negative impact of the restoration process. Public opinion is very important in the feasibility of a restoration; if the public believes that the costs of restoration outweigh the benefits, then support for that project is unlikely to be big, especially in small towns (MacDonald et al. 2002). In these cases people might be ready to follow the abandonment route and let the ecosystem recover on its own, which can sometimes occur relatively quickly (Holl, 2006).

Many failures have occurred in past restoration projects, many times because clear goals were not set out as the aim of the restoration. This may be because, as Peter Alpert says, “people may not know how to manage natural systems effectively”. Also many assumptions are made about myths of restoration such as the carbon copy, where a restoration plan, which worked in one area, is applied to another with the same results expected, but not realized (Hilderbrand et al. 2005).

Read more about this topic:  Ecosystem Restoration

Famous quotes containing the words problems and/or restoration:

    Men decide far more problems by hate, love, lust, rage, sorrow, joy, hope, fear, illusion, or some other inward emotion than by reality, authority, any legal standard, judicial precedent, or statute.
    Marcus Tullius Cicero (106–43 B.C.)

    I claim that in losing the spinning wheel we lost our left lung. We are, therefore, suffering from galloping consumption. The restoration of the wheel arrests the progress of the fell disease.
    Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869–1948)