David and The Phoenix - Major Themes

Major Themes

The book might be interpreted as an extended metaphor for the supposed inability of Science and Mythology to coexist. The Scientist represents a certain aspect of science which seeks to destroy things outside its paradigm. However, as the scientist uses a gun and deadly traps, it also might be a criticism of endangered species—the author is also a known environmentalist who has long fought to preserve the Finger Lakes region of New York, where he currently resides.

However, Edward Ormondroyd's major theme seems to be the ongoing conflict between childhood and adulthood—instead of putting away "childish things," the older Phoenix seeks to educate David (and the reader) that adults can also have imaginations, and can enjoy fantasy on its own merits. Too often, parents and teachers discourage fantasy literature as being frivolous and unprofitable—the Phoenix argues that without mythology, David's education is not complete.

David meets many mythological creatures, including; The eponymous Phoenix, Griffins, Fauns, Sea Monsters, a Banshee, Nymphs, and Leprechauns. However, the author concludes that fantasy should not be confused with reality—the Phoenix actually rescues David from falling permanently under the influence of the magical world; instead, he returns the boy to his home.