Criticism of Conservative Judaism

Criticism of Conservative Judaism is widespread in the Orthodox Jewish community, although the movement also has its critics in Reform Judaism and in other streams of Judaism. While the Conservative movement professes fidelity to Jewish tradition, it considers Halakha (Jewish religious law) to be a dynamic process that needs reinterpreting in modern times. The criticism by Orthodox Jews and traditionalists within the movement itself revolves around the following:

  • Conservative Judaism, or some of its decisions and positions, does not follow halakha, because:
    • The legal analyses of its rabbinate deconstruct or manipulate religious obligations, rather than being faithful to and fostering respect for them;
    • It hoists certain historical or cultural assumptions onto a law, then disavows the assumption, granting itself license to disavow the law itself;
    • It issues "emergency decrees" in the absence of legitimate emergencies, rather than following a legitimate, faithful, or reverential approach to halakha;
    • Its decisions consistently lead to more lax, rather than stringent or balanced observance;
    • It generally makes communal decrees through a council of (often lay) leaders, rather than relying exclusively on Talmudic scholars, resulting in decisions reflecting popular opinion rather than scholarship; and
    • Accommodating the values and likeness of the broader society has taken precedence over a dedication to the internal integrity of halakhic sources.

Critics also claim that the legal analysis of the Conservative movement tends to be ideologically-driven, resulting in intended outcomes to such an extent that it is outside the bounds of traditional halakhic analysis.

Read more about Criticism Of Conservative Judaism:  Criticism From Orthodoxy, Criticism From Conservative Traditionalists, Criticism From Reform Jews, Criticism From Third-wave Feminists

Famous quotes containing the words criticism, conservative and/or judaism:

    I consider criticism merely a preliminary excitement, a statement of things a writer has to clear up in his own head sometime or other, probably antecedent to writing; of no value unless it come to fruit in the created work later.
    Ezra Pound (1885–1972)

    The most radical revolutionary will become a conservative the day after the revolution.
    Hannah Arendt (1906–1975)

    Christianity is the religion of melancholy and hypochondria. Islam, on the other hand, promotes apathy, and Judaism instills its adherents with a certain choleric vehemence, the heathen Greeks may well be called happy optimists.
    Franz Grillparzer (1791–1872)