2000/2001 Franchise Controversy
There were 2 companies competing for the National Lottery franchise in 2001, Camelot, the incumbent operator and a rival operator organised by Sir Richard Branson called The People's Lottery.
During the 2000 franchise bidding process, a technical problem with lottery terminals supplied by American company GTECH Corporation came to light. It was discovered that this technical problem may have inadvertently caused winners to be paid incorrect amounts and it was this problem and the relationship between Camelot and GTECH that saw the National Lottery Commission recommend the lottery franchise be awarded to The People's Lottery. GTECH originally were a shareholder in Camelot Group but they later sold their shareholding to Camelot Group with the remaining shareholders increasing their stakes from 16.66% to 20%.
In August 2000 the chair of the National Lottery Commission, Dame Helena Shovelton stunned both parties when she announced that neither party would be invited to run the National Lottery, claiming that neither party met the statutory requirements to run the lottery. It was felt legal problems were responsible for the downfall of The People's Lottery bid whilst the relationship between G-Tech and Camelot was the reason Camelot would not be invited to run the lottery. Despite the fact that neither bid met the statutory requirements, the Commission still tried to award the franchise to The People's Lottery.
By September 2000 it was clear that despite neither party meeting the statutory requirements to run the lottery, the Commission was going to award the franchise to The People's Lottery. It was at this point that Camelot initiated legal action, taking the Commission to the high court for a judicial review. The High Court judges sided with Camelot, describing the Commissions decision as "conspicuously unfair". The National Lottery Commission responded by dismissing the Treasury legal team who had been advising them. Dame Helena resigned shortly afterwards and was replaced by Lord Burns.
During November, the National Lottery Commission reopened the bidding process and both parties resubmitted their bids, the commission hoped to announce the winner by mid-December. On December 19, 2000 the commission announced that Camelot would be awarded the franchise, with voting 4-1 in favour of Camelot. One member would later resign from the commission over the whole process, deeply unhappy that Camelot had been reawarded the franchise. It was during the second bidding process that Camelot agreed to buy out shareholder G-Tech's stake in the company. Sir Richard Branson threatened to take further legal action but faced with the prospect of a lengthy and costly legal battle, one which could have eventually resulted in The National Lottery games being suspended, he backed down.
Read more about this topic: Camelot Group
Famous quotes containing the words franchise and/or controversy:
“To-day women constitute the only class of sane people excluded from the franchise ...”
—Mary Putnam Jacobi (1842–1906)
“Ours was a highly activist administration, with a lot of controversy involved ... but I’m not sure that it would be inconsistent with my own political nature to do it differently if I had it to do all over again.”
—Jimmy Carter (James Earl Carter, Jr.)