David Graeber's Value As "meaning-making"
David Graeber attempts to synthesize the insights of Karl Marx and Marcel Mauss. He sees value as a model for human "meaning-making". Starting with Marxist definitions of consumption and production, he introduces Mauss’s idea of "objects that are not consumed" and posits that the majority of human behavior consists of activities that would not be properly categorized as either consumption or production. To illustrate this principle, one of Graeber’s undergraduate students at Yale, David Corson-Knowles, began a list of things that are neither consumption nor production in 2003, which has since been expanded and expounded upon. This list includes those human activities that are not consumption, in the narrow sense of simply purchasing something, and are not production, in the sense of creating or modifying something intended for sale or exchange, namely:
- cooking a meal
- extinguishing a fire
- dressing and undressing
- applying makeup
- watching television
- playing in a band
- falling in love
- reading
- listening to music
- going to a museum or gallery
- taking a photograph
- gardening
- writing
- conducting a coming of age ceremony
- going window shopping
- exercising
- acting
- turning around in a circle
- teaching
- having an argument
- playing games
- having sex
- attending a religious service
- looking at old photos
- critiquing art
Read more about this topic: Anthropological Theories Of Value
Famous quotes containing the word david:
“We noticed several other sandy tracts in our voyage; and the course of the Merrimack can be traced from the nearest mountain by its yellow sand-banks, though the river itself is for the most part invisible. Lawsuits, as we hear, have in some cases grown out of these causes. Railroads have been made through certain irritable districts, breaking their sod, and so have set the sand to blowing, till it has converted fertile farms into deserts, and the company has had to pay the damages.”
—Henry David Thoreau (1817–1862)