Awards and Nominations
- Outer Critics Circle Award Best Off Broadway Musical (winner)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical (nominee)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (Tyler Maynard, nominee)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Choreography (Christopher Gattelli, nominee)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Music (Gary Adler & Michael Patrick Walker, nominees)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Lyrics (Gary Adler & Michael Patrick Walker, nominees)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Book of a Musical (Kevin Del Aguila, nominee)
- Drama Desk Award Outstanding Orchestrations (Doug Katsaros & Lynne Shankel, nominees)
- Lucille Lortel Award Outstanding Musical (nominee)
- Lucille Lortel Award Outstanding Choreography (Christopher Gattelli, winner)
- Lucille Lortel Award Outstanding Featured Actor (Tyler Maynard, nominee)
- Lucille Lortel Award Outstanding Sound Design (Simon Matthews, nominee)
- Drama League Award Distinguished Production of a Musical (nominee)
- Drama League Award Distinguished Performance Award (Ryan Duncan, David Josefsberg, Andy Karl, Tyler Maynard, Scott Porter, nominees)
- Theatre World Award (Tyler Maynard, winner)
Read more about this topic: Altar Boyz