Accusation Process and Punishment
Given the severity of punishment for the offense of zina, the Qur'an requires solid proof beyond the shadow of doubt before convicting an individual, be it a man or a woman, of zina. Muslim jurists have derived from the Sunnah of Muhammad very strict requirements for proving zina. In fact, jurists unanimously agree on only two means of doing so:
- A clear, free, and willful confession by the person guilty of the act of zina. However, if that person retracts his/her confession, he/she is not punishable (barring the presence of witnesses, as indicated below), because there would no longer be any proof of the occurrence of the prohibited act, and alternatively,
- The testimony of four reliable Muslim male eye-witnesses, all of whom must have witnessed the actual intercourse at the same time.
It is pertinent to point out that the evidentiary requirement for zina was initially intended to protect men and women from frivolous charges. This intention derives directly from Asbab al-nuzul (reasons of revelation) relating to the Qur'anic verse that establishes the hadd of zina. Therefore it is believed that the requirement of four witnesses (with all its restrictions and specifications) is considered a merciful measure from God in order to not only avoid incriminating innocent people, but also to preserve the privacy of Muslims, which is one of the most valued principles in Islam.
In the case of a confession, it is recommended that the judge ignore the first three iterations of such confession. The confession does not become legally binding unless it is repeated freely four different times.
Read more about this topic: Zina
Famous quotes containing the words accusation, process and/or punishment:
“The only obligation to which in advance we may hold a novel, without incurring the accusation of being arbitrary, is that it be interesting.”
—Henry James (1843–1916)
“We are in the process of creating what deserves to be called the idiot culture. Not an idiot sub-culture, which every society has bubbling beneath the surface and which can provide harmless fun; but the culture itself. For the first time, the weird and the stupid and the coarse are becoming our cultural norm, even our cultural ideal.”
—Carl Bernstein (b. 1944)
“Let us have compassion for those under chastisement. Alas, who are we ourselves? Who am I and who are you? Whence do we come and is it quite certain that we did nothing before we were born? This earth is not without some resemblance to a gaol. Who knows but that man is a victim of divine justice? Look closely at life. It is so constituted that one senses punishment everywhere.”
—Victor Hugo (1802–1885)