Robert MacLean Alleges That The Merit Systems Protection Board Distorted The Record in Order To Canc
In his United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit briefs, MacLean alleges that the United States Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) distorted the record in order to cancel out his "good faith belief" defenses afforded to him by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in their September 16, 2008 decision:
| “ |
MacLean may still contest his termination before the MSPB, where he may raise the Whistleblower Protection Act (WPA) of 1989 and contend that the lack of clarity of the TSA's 2003 'sensitive security information' regulations is evidence MacLean disseminated the text message under a good faith belief the information did not qualify as 'sensitive security information'. |
” |
MacLean's allegations are supported in the entire history of the TSA's filings and the MSPB's July 25, 2011 final decision. Both the TSA and MSPB consistently omit a key quote from a TSA lawyer during MacLean's August 2, 2006 deposition.
Despite his consistent testimony to the internal affairs investigators and to the MSPB administrative judge that he believed he did not disclose SSI or classified information to the reporter, the MSPB ruled that since MacLean once told the TSA lawyer in his August 2, 2006 deposition that "it did not matter" if he had disclosed SSI or classified information to a supervisory Federal Air Marshal, MacLean would have disclosed the information to the reporter regardless of whether or not it was classified or marked SSI. In the TSA's preceding briefs filed with the MSPB and the MSPB's July 25, 2011 final decision, both omitted the fact that MacLean's response was to the TSA lawyers question about his July 2003 conversation with a supervisory Federal Air Marshal, not a reporter. In their exchange during the August 2, 2006, both MacLean and the TSA lawyer make no mention of the reporter or any member of the media:
| “ |
PAGE 91: TSA lawyer: In discussing the cancellation of RON missions, with Mr. Scoffield, did you know whether or not you, were discussing sensitive security information? MacLean: It did not matter. TSA lawyer: Why didn't it matter? MacLean: Because the law was being broken and the public was being endangered, and it was an abuse of, authority. Public lives were at risk. It did not matter to me whether it was, confidential, law enforcement sensitive, or, classified information. It was breaking the ] law and it, was endangering life. |
” |
MacLean argues that the omission of the TSA lawyer's question, regarding the supervisory Federal Air Marshal, invalidates the TSA and MSPB's claims that MacLean did not have a "good faith belief."
Read more about this topic: Robert Mac Lean
Famous quotes containing the words board, order, record, distorted, protection, systems and/or merit:
“What happens in a strike happens not to one person alone.... It is a crisis with meaning and potency for all and prophetic of a future. The elements in crisis are the same, there is a fermentation that is identical. The elements are these: a body of men, women and children, hungry; an organization of feudal employers out to break the back of unionization; and the government Labor Board sent to “negotiate” between this hunger and this greed.”
—Meridel Le Sueur (b. 1900)
“But then people don’t read literature in order to understand; they read it because they want to re-live the feelings and sensations which they found exciting in the past. Art can be a lot of things; but in actual practice, most of it is merely the mental equivalent of alcohol and cantharides.”
—Aldous Huxley (1894–1963)
“Human beings are compelled to live within a lie, but they can be compelled to do so only because they are in fact capable of living in this way. Therefore not only does the system alienate humanity, but at the same time alienated humanity supports this system as its own involuntary masterplan, as a degenerate image of its own degeneration, as a record of people’s own failure as individuals.”
—Václav Havel (b. 1936)
“The grand principles of virtue and honor, however they may be distorted by arbitrary codes, are the same the world over: and where these principles are concerned, the right or wrong of any action appears the same to the uncultivated as to the enlightened mind.”
—Herman Melville (1819–1891)
“We cannot spare our children the influence of harmful values by turning off the television any more than we can keep them home forever or revamp the world before they get there. Merely keeping them in the dark is no protection and, in fact, can make them vulnerable and immature.”
—Polly Berrien Berends (20th century)
“No civilization ... would ever have been possible without a framework of stability, to provide the wherein for the flux of change. Foremost among the stabilizing factors, more enduring than customs, manners and traditions, are the legal systems that regulate our life in the world and our daily affairs with each other.”
—Hannah Arendt (1906–1975)
“Persistence in a single view has never been regarded as a merit in political leaders.”
—Marcus Tullius Cicero (106–43 B.C.)