Awards and Nominations
| Year | Award | Category | Nominee | Result | Ref |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | Obie Award | Special Citations | Hunter Bell, Michael Berresse and Jeff Bowen | Won | |
| Drama League Award | Distinguished Production of a Musical | Nominated | |||
| Distinguished Performance Award | Ensemble | Nominated | |||
| 2007 | GLAAD Media Awards | Outstanding New York Theatre: Broadway and Off-Broadway | Hunter Bell and Jeff Bowen | Nominated | |
| 2009 | Tony Award | Best Book of a Musical | Hunter Bell | Nominated | |
| Broadway.com Audience Choice Award | Favorite New Broadway Musical | Nominated | |||
| Favorite Ensemble Cast | Won | ||||
| Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical | Susan Blackwell | Nominated | |||
| Heidi Blickenstaff | Nominated | ||||
| Favorite Breakthrough Performance (Female) | Susan Blackwell | Nominated | |||
| Heidi Blickenstaff | Nominated | ||||
| Favorite Breakthrough Performance (Male) | Hunter Bell | Nominated | |||
| Favorite Diva Performance | Heidi Blickenstaff | Nominated | |||
| Favorite New Broadway Song | "A Way Back to Then" | Nominated | |||
| "Nine People's Favorite Thing" | Nominated | ||||
Read more about this topic: Title Of Show