- 1990: Patrick McGoohan – Columbo: Agenda for Murder as Oscar Finch
- Peter Frechette – thirtysomething as Peter Montefiore
- Harold Gould – The Ray Bradbury Theater as the Old Man
- William Hickey – Tales from the Crypt as Carlton Webster
- Bruce Weitz – Midnight Caller as Sgt. Ed Adderly
- 1991: David Opatoshu – Gabriel's Fire as Max Goldstein
- Dabney Coleman – Columbo and the Murder of a Rock Star as Hugh Creighton
- Peter Coyote – Road to Avonlea as Romney Penhallow
- John Glover – L.A. Law as Dr. Paul Kohler
- 1993: Laurence Fishburne – Tribeca as Martin McHenry
- Adam Arkin – Northern Exposure as Adam
- John Glover – Crime & Punishment as Dennis Atwood
- Michael Jeter – Picket Fences as Peter LeBeck (Frog Man)
- Richard Kiley – Picket Fences as Hayden Langston
- 1994: Richard Kiley – Picket Fences as Hayden Langston
- Tim Curry – Tales from the Crypt as Mother/Father/Sister/Daughter
- Dan Hedaya – NYPD Blue as Lou the Werewolf
- James Earl Jones – Picket Fences as Attorney Bryant Thomas
- Robin Williams – Homicide: Life on the Street as Robert Ellison
|
- 1995: Paul Winfield – Picket Fences as Judge Harold Nance
- Milton Berle – Beverly Hills, 90210 as Saul Howard
- Beau Bridges – The Outer Limits as Simon Kress
- Vondie Curtis-Hall – ER as Rena
- Alan Rosenberg – ER as Sam Gasner
- 1996: Peter Boyle – The X-Files as Clyde Bruckman
- Danny Glover – Fallen Angels as Phllip Marlow
- Michael Jeter – Chicago Hope as Bob Ryan
- Richard Pryor – Chicago Hope as Joe Springer
- Rip Torn – Chicago Hope as Warren Shutt
- 1997: Pruitt Taylor Vince – Murder One as Clifford Banks
- Alan Arkin – Chicago Hope as Zoltan Karpathein
- Louis Gossett Jr. – Touched by an Angel as Anderson Walker
- William H. Macy – ER as Dr. David Morgenstern
- Ewan McGregor – ER as Duncan Stewart
- 1998: John Larroquette – The Practice as Joey Heric
- Vincent D'Onofrio – Homicide: Life on the Street as John Lange
- Bruce Davison – Touched by an Angel as Jacob 'Jake' Weiss
- Charles Durning – Homicide: Life on the Street as Thomas Finnegan
- Charles Nelson Reilly – Millennium as Jose Chung
- 1999: Edward Herrmann – The Practice as Anderson Pearson
- Tony Danza – The Practice as Attorney Tommy Silva
- Charles S. Dutton – Oz as Professor Alvah Case
- John Heard – The Sopranos as Det. Vin Makazian
- Mandy Patinkin – Chicago Hope as Dr. Jeffrey Geiger
|