Year-by-year
| Year | Division | League | Reg. season | Playoffs | Challenge Cup | American Cup |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1917/18 | 1 | NAFBL | 1st | No playoff | Quarterfinals | ? |
| 1918/19 | 1 | NAFBL | 3rd | No playoff | Runner Up | Runner Up |
| 1919/20 | 1 | NAFBL | 4th | No playoff | ? | ? |
| 1920/21 | 1 | NAFBL | Withdrew | No playoff | Third round | Third round |
| 1922/23 | 1 | ASL | 5th | No playoff | Champion | Semifinals |
Read more about this topic: Paterson F.C. (NAFBL)