Player |
Position |
Year |
Unanimous |
Consensus |
Selectors |
Cunningham, William |
C |
1898 |
No |
Yes |
CW-1 |
Steckle, Allen |
T |
1898 |
No |
No |
WC-2 |
McLean, John |
HB |
1899 |
No |
No |
PI |
France, Richard |
G |
1899 |
No |
No |
PI |
Snow, Neil |
E |
1899 |
No |
No |
PI |
Snow, Neil |
E |
1901 |
? |
Yes |
|
Maddock, Joe |
T |
1902 |
No |
No |
NA |
Weeks, Boss |
QB |
1902 |
No |
No |
NA |
Heston, Willie |
HB |
1902 |
No |
No |
NA; CW-2 |
Heston, Willie |
HB |
1903 |
No |
Yes |
WC-1; CW-1; FY-1; SA-1 |
Graver, Herb |
HB |
1903 |
No |
No |
WC-3 |
Maddock, Joe |
T |
1903 |
No |
No |
WC-3; CW-2; FY-1; SA-1 |
Redden, Curtis |
E |
1903 |
No |
No |
WC-3 |
Heston, Willie |
HB|HB |
1904 |
|
Yes |
WC-1, NYET, FL |
Curtis, Joe |
T |
1904 |
No |
No |
WC-2, FL |
Curtis, Joe |
T |
1905 |
No |
No |
WC-2 |
Hammond, Thomas |
HB |
1905 |
No |
No |
WC-3 |
Schulte, Henry |
G |
1905 |
No |
No |
WC-2 |
Garrels, John |
FB |
1906 |
No |
No |
WC-3 |
Schulz, Germany |
C |
1907 |
No |
Yes |
WC-1; CW-2; FY-1 |
Rheinschild, Walter |
T |
1907 |
No |
No |
FY-1 |
Schulz, Germany |
C |
1908 |
No |
No |
CON-2 ; NYW; PI; FY; TT; CSM; NYET; BSU; BP; PD; NHR; TJ; KCJ; PP; PT; PES |
Casey, Wiliam |
T |
1909 |
No |
No |
|
Benbrook, Albert |
G |
1909 |
No |
Yes |
WC-1 |
Allerdice, Dave |
HB |
1909 |
No |
No |
WC-2; NYT-1; TC-1 |
Magidsohn, Joe |
HB |
1909 |
No |
No |
WC-2 |
Benbrook, Albert |
G |
1910 |
No |
Yes |
WC–1; TC-1; OUT; ES; LES; TEL |
Wells, Stanfield |
E |
1910 |
|
Yes |
WC-1; OUT |
Magidsohn, Joe |
HB |
1910 |
No |
No |
TC-1; OUT; TEL |
Wells, Stanfield |
E |
1911 |
|
No |
WC-3 ; NYG-1; HW-1; HL |
Pontius, Miller |
T |
1912 |
No |
No |
ASH-1 |
Pontius, Miller |
T |
1913 |
No |
Yes |
NS-1; MFP-2; FY-1; PHD-1; TT-1 |
Craig, James |
HB|HB |
1913 |
No |
Yes |
WC–1; HW-1; INS-1; MFP-1; FY-1; TT-1; TET-1 |
Paterson, "Bubbles" |
C |
1913 |
No |
No |
WC–3; MFP-1 |
Hughitt, Ernest |
QB |
1913 |
No |
No |
MFP-2; FY-1 |
Maulbetsch, John |
HB |
1914 |
Yes |
Yes |
WC–1; VF ; PHD; WE–1; FM-1; MO-1; PGT ; BN; AC; PS; DD; PET; SLT; MD; NES; DN; PPL; BP; AW; PI; OUT |
Maulbetsch, John |
HB |
1915 |
No |
No |
WE-2; MON-2; TC-1 |
Sparks, Cliff |
QB |
1916 |
No |
No |
MON-1 |
Maulbetsch, John |
HB |
1916 |
No |
No |
FY-1 |
Smith, Cedric "Pat" |
FB |
1917 |
No |
No |
|
Allmendinger, Ernest |
G |
1917 |
No |
No |
|
Culver, Frank |
G |
1917 |
No |
No |
WC–1; NEA; JV-2; PP-1 |
Lambert, Oscar |
C |
1917 |
No |
No |
WE-2 |
Weston, Archie |
Q |
1917 |
No |
No |
WE-1 |
Steketee, Frank |
FB |
1918 |
No |
No |
WC-1; BM-2 |
Goetz, Angus |
T |
1918 |
No |
No |
WC-3 |
Goetz, Angus |
T |
1920 |
No |
No |
WC-2 |
Wieman, Elton |
T |
1920 |
No |
No |
LP-2 |
Vick, Ernie |
C |
1921 |
No |
No |
(FW-3; WC-1; WE-3; MM-2 |
Goebel, Paul |
E |
1921 |
No |
No |
LP-1 |
Dunne, Robert J. |
G |
1921 |
No |
No |
NB-1 |
Cappon, Franklin |
T |
1921 |
No |
No |
NB-2 |
Goebel, Paul |
E |
1922 |
No |
No |
NYT-1; NB-1; AW-1; LP-1; BE; RO-1 |
Kirk, Bernard |
E |
1922 |
No |
No |
WC-2; NYT-1; WE-1; NB-2; LP-2; BE; FH-1; RO-2 |
Uteritz, Irwin |
Q |
1922 |
No |
No |
WC-3; WE-3; FM-1; RO-5 |
Kipke, Harry |
HB |
1922 |
No |
Yes |
WC-1; NYT-2; AW-1; WE-1; NB-1; LP-1 ; BE; RO-2 |
Muirhead, Stanley |
T |
1922 |
No |
No |
LP-2; RO-4 |
Cappon, Franklin |
FB |
1922 |
No |
No |
WE-3; NYT-2 ; FH-2; RO-5 |
Slaughter, Edliff |
G |
1923 |
No |
No |
LP-1 |
Blott, Jack |
C |
1923 |
No |
Yes |
AW-1; WC-1; NB-1; DW-1 |
Kipke, Harry |
HB |
1923 |
No |
No |
AW-2; LP-1; TT-3 |
Muirhead, Stanley |
T |
1923 |
No |
No |
AW-2; LP-2; NB-2 |
Slaughter, Edliff |
G |
1924 |
No |
No |
WC-1; LP-1; BE-2; NB-1 |
Hawkins, Harry |
G |
1925 |
No |
No |
JRW-3; WE-3 |
Brown, Robert J. |
C |
1925 |
No |
No |
AP-2; COL-2; A&S-1; Sun–2; BE-1; NB-1 |
Edwards, Tom |
T |
1925 |
No |
No |
AP-2; COL-2; A&S-1; Sun–2; BE-1; NB-1 |
Friedman, Benny |
QB |
1925 |
No |
Yes |
UP-1; AP-2; COL-2; JRW-1; Sun–1; WE–2; BE-2 |
Oosterbaan, Bennie |
E |
1925 |
? |
Yes |
UP-1; AP-1; COL-1; A&S-1; JRW-1; Sun-1; WC; WE–1; BE-1; NB-1 |
Friedman, Benny |
QB |
1926 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; COL-1; CP-1; NYS-1; BE-1; RWJ-2; RG-1; DW-1; ES-1 |
Oosterbaan, Bennie |
E |
1925 |
? |
Yes |
AP-3; COL-1; CP-1; WC-1; BE-1; RWJ-1; RG-2; ES-1 |
Oosterbaan, Bennie |
E |
1927 |
|
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; COL-1; CP-1; HE-1; DJW-1; NYS-1; BE-1; LP-1 |
Pommerening, Otto |
T |
1928 |
No |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; CO-1 |
Newman, Harry |
QB |
1930 |
No |
No |
INS-3 |
Morrison, Maynard |
C |
1931 |
No |
No |
AP–3; COL–1; NEA-1; CP–3 |
Hewitt, Bill |
E |
1931 |
No |
No |
NEA-3 |
Newman, Harry |
QB |
1932 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; CO-1; AAB-1; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1; NYT-1; WC-1; TR-1 |
Bernard, Chuck |
C |
1932 |
No |
No |
AP-3; NEA-1; INS-1 |
Petoskey, Ted |
E |
1932 |
No |
No |
WC-1; AAB-1; INS-3; NYS-2 |
Bernard, Chuck |
C |
1933 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; CO-1; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1; WC-1; DJW-1; WD-1 |
Petoskey, Ted |
E |
1933 |
No |
No |
AP-2; UP-2; CO-2; INS-1; CP-1 |
Wistert, Francis |
T |
1933 |
No |
Yes |
UP-1; CO-1; INS-2; CP-2; NYS-1; WC-1; DJW-1; WD-1 |
Everhardus, Herman |
HB |
1933 |
No |
No |
COL-3; NEA-2; INS-2 |
Patanelli, Matt |
E |
1936 |
No |
No |
AP-3; CP-2 |
Ralph Heikkinen |
G |
1938 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; CP-1; CO-1; NEA-1; NYS-1; WC-1 |
Harmon, Tom |
HB |
1939 |
|
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; CO-1; CP-1; INS-1; NEA-3; NYS-1 ; WC-1; NW-1 (2nd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Harmon, Tom |
HB |
1940 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; HE-1; CP-1; CO-1; NEA-1; NYS-1; WC-1 (Heisman Trophy winner) |
Frutig, Ed |
E |
1940 |
No |
No |
AP-3; UP-3; HE-1; CP-3 |
Westfall, Bob |
FB |
1941 |
|
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; AAB-1; CO-1; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1; WC-1 |
Franks, Julius |
G |
1942 |
No |
|
AP-2; SN-3; INS-1; CP-1; NEA-2; CO-1; NYS-2 |
Wistert, Albert |
T |
1942 |
|
|
AP-2; UP-1; SN-2; CP-3; NEA-3; LK-1; NYS-1; WC-1; MS-1 |
Pregulman, Merv |
T |
1942 |
No |
No |
SN-3; NEA-1; MS-1 |
Pregulman, Merv |
T |
1943 |
No |
|
CO-1; SS-1 |
Daley, Bill |
FB |
1943 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-; CO-1; SS-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1 |
Lazetich, Milan |
T |
1944 |
No |
No |
AP-2; UP-3; FWAA-2; INS-2; CP-2 |
Madar, Elmer |
E |
1946 |
No |
No |
AP-1; INS-2; CP-3 |
Chappuis, Bob |
HB |
1947 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; PO-1; CO-1; NEA-1; CP-1; INS-1; WC-1; FW-1 (2nd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
White, J.T. |
C |
1947 |
No |
No. |
FWAA-2 |
Elliott, Bump |
HB |
1947 |
No |
|
AP-2; UP-2; PO-1; NEA-3; CP-2; INS-3; FW-2 |
Elliott, Pete |
QB |
1948 |
No |
No |
INS-1 |
Rifenburg, Dick |
E |
1948 |
|
|
AP-1; UP-1; NEA-1; CP-1; INS-1 ; WC-1; FW-1 |
Wistert, Alvin |
T |
1948 |
|
|
UP-1; CO-1; NEA-2; CP-1; WC-1; FW-2 |
Kempthorn, Dick |
FB |
1949 |
|
|
AP-2; UP-2; FWAA-3 |
Ortmann, Chuck |
HB |
1949 |
|
|
FWAA-2 |
Wahl, Robert |
T |
1949 |
No |
No |
NEA-1 (offense); FWAA-1 |
Wistert, Alvin |
T |
1949 |
|
|
WC-1; AP-3; UP-1; TSN; INS-1 (defense) |
Wahl, Robert |
T |
1950 |
|
|
AP (defense)-1; UP-2; INS (offense)-1; CP-2 |
Ortmann, Chuck |
HB |
1950 |
|
|
CP-3 |
Perry, Lowell |
E |
1951 |
|
|
|
Walker, Art |
T |
1954 |
|
|
FWAA-1 |
Kramer, Ron |
E |
1954 |
|
|
AP-3; UP-3; CP-1; INS-2 |
Kramer, Ron |
E |
1955 |
|
|
UP-1; AFCA; FWAA; TSN; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-2; WC |
Maentz, Tom |
E |
1955 |
|
|
AP-2; UP-2; CP-3 |
Kramer, Ron |
E |
1956 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP-1; UP-1; TSN-1; CO-1; INS-1; CP-1; NEA-1; WC-1; FWAA-1 (6th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Pace, Jim |
HB |
1957 |
No |
No |
AP-1 |
Bob Timberlake |
QB |
1964 |
No |
|
AP, FWAA, FN (4th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Yearby, Bill |
DT |
1964 |
|
|
NEA, CP, FN |
Yearby, Bill |
DT |
1965 |
|
Yes |
UPI, CP, WC, AFCA, Time, TSN |
Clancy, Jack |
E |
1966 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, CP, WC, AFCA, FWAA, Time, TSN |
Volk, Rick |
DB |
1966 |
|
|
Time, TSN |
Johnson, Ron |
HB |
1968 |
|
|
FWAA, FN |
Curtis, Tom |
DB |
1969 |
|
|
AP, UPI, WC, CP, FN |
Mandich, Jim |
TE |
1969 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, CP, Time, FN |
Huff, Marty |
LB |
1970 |
|
|
AFCA |
Dierdorf, Dan |
OT |
1970 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, FWAA, WC, AFCA, Time, PFW, FN |
Hill, Henry |
G |
1970 |
|
|
CP |
McKenzie, Reggie |
OG |
1971 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, FWAA, TSN, Time, FN |
Darden, Thom |
DB |
1971 |
|
|
AFCA, TSN |
Taylor, Billy |
RB |
1971 |
|
|
FN |
Taylor, Mike |
LB |
1971 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, Time, FN |
Seymour, Paul |
OT |
1972 |
|
|
NEA, FWAA, AFCA, TSN, Time |
Logan, Randy |
DB |
1972 |
|
|
UPI, WC, AFCA, FN |
Gallagher, Dave |
DT |
1973 |
|
|
AP, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, Time |
Brown, Dave |
DB |
1973 |
|
|
UPI, AFCA, FWAA |
Lantry, Mike |
PK |
1973 |
|
|
FN |
Brown, Dave |
DB |
1974 |
|
|
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, FN, Time |
Dufek, Don |
DB |
1975 |
|
|
WC, FWAA, FN |
Lytle, Rob |
RB |
1976 |
|
|
AP, UPI, WC, AFCA, FN, CFN (3rd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
O'Neal, Calvin |
LB |
1976 |
|
|
UPI, WC, TSN, CFN |
Smith, Jim |
WR |
1976 |
|
|
AP, TSN, FN, FWAA |
Donahue, Mark |
OG |
1976 |
|
|
UPI, NEA, WC, FWAA, FN |
Donahue, Mark |
OG |
1977 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, FN |
Anderson, John |
LB |
1977 |
|
|
FWAA |
Downing, Walt |
C |
1977 |
|
|
AFCA, TSN, FN |
Leach, Rick |
QB |
1978 |
|
|
AFCA-t (3rd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Simpkins, Ron |
LB |
1979 |
|
|
AP, UPI, WC, FWAA |
Greer, Curtis |
DT |
1979 |
|
|
NEA, AFCA, FWAA |
Lilja, George |
C |
1980 |
|
|
WC |
Carter, Anthony |
WR |
1980 |
|
|
AP, TSN |
Carter, Anthony |
WR |
1981 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN |
Muransky, Ed |
OT |
1981 |
|
|
|
Paris, Bubba |
OT |
1981 |
|
|
WC |
Becker, Kurt |
OG |
1981 |
|
|
AP, NEA, AFCA |
Woolfolk, Butch |
RB |
1981 |
|
|
|
Carter, Anthony |
WR |
1982 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN (4th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Dixon, Tom |
C |
1983 |
|
|
AP, AFCA, TSN |
Humphries, Stefan |
OG |
1983 |
|
|
UPI, FWAA, TSN |
Cochran, Brad |
DB |
1985 |
|
|
UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA |
Hammerstein, Mike |
DT |
1985 |
|
|
AP, UPI, AFCA |
Harbaugh, Jim |
QB |
1986 |
No |
No |
UPI-2 (finished 3rd in Heisman Trophy voting behind Miami QB Vinny Testaverde) |
Rivers, Garland |
DB |
1986 |
|
|
NEA, WC, AFCA |
Elliott, Jumbo |
OT |
1986 |
No |
No |
AFCA |
Elliott, Jumbo |
OT |
1987 |
|
|
UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA |
Messner, Mark |
DT |
1987 |
No |
No |
TSN |
Messner, Mark |
DT |
1988 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN |
Vitale, John |
C |
1988 |
No |
|
UPI, WC |
Welborne, Tripp |
DB |
1989 |
|
Yes |
AP, UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA, FN, TSN |
Welborne, Tripp |
DB |
1990 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, SH, TSN, FN |
Dingman, Dean |
OG |
1990 |
No |
No |
AFCA, TSN |
Skrepenak, Greg |
OT |
1990 |
No |
No |
WC |
Skrepenak, Greg |
OT |
1991 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, SH, TSN, FN |
Elliott, Matt |
OG |
1991 |
No |
No |
|
Anderson, Erick |
LB |
1991 |
No |
No |
UPI |
Howard, Desmond |
WR |
1991 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, SH, TSN, FN (Heisman Trophy winner) |
Hutchinson, Chris |
DT |
1992 |
No |
|
AFCA, FWAA, SH, FN |
Alexander, Derrick |
WR |
1992 |
No |
|
|
Cocozzo, Joe |
OG |
1992 |
No |
No |
|
Wheatley, Tyrone |
RB |
1993 |
No |
No |
SH |
Hamilton, Remy |
PK |
1994 |
No |
No |
|
Law, Ty |
DB |
1994 |
No |
No |
WC |
Horn, Jason |
DT |
1995 |
No |
No |
AFCA |
Runyan, Jon |
OT |
1995 |
No |
No |
|
Carr, Will |
DT |
1996 |
No |
No |
|
Irons, Jarrett |
LB |
1996 |
No |
|
AP, AFCA, WC |
Payne, Rod |
C |
1996 |
No |
No |
AFCA |
Woodson, Charles |
DB |
1996 |
No |
|
AP, FWAA |
Woodson, Charles |
DB |
1997 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, TSN, FN (Heisman Trophy winner) |
Tuman, Jerame |
TE |
1997 |
No |
No |
FN |
Steele, Glen |
DT |
1997 |
No |
No |
AFCA |
Jansen, Jon |
OT |
1998 |
No |
No |
AFCA |
Renes, Rob |
DT |
1999 |
No |
No |
TSN |
Hutchinson, Steve |
OG |
1999 |
No |
No |
PFW, CNNSI |
Hutchinson, Steve |
OG |
2000 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, WC, AFCA, FWAA, PFW, FN, CNNSI, Rivals |
Terrell, David |
WR |
2000 |
No |
|
PFW, CNNSI, Rivals |
Foote, Larry |
LB |
2001 |
No |
No |
FN |
Walker, Marquise |
WR |
2001 |
No |
No |
AFCA |
Joppru, Bennie |
TE |
2002 |
No |
No |
PFW |
Jackson, Marlin |
DB |
2002 |
No |
No |
PFW |
Perry, Chris |
RB |
2003 |
No |
|
AP, AFCA, WC, TSN, PFW, SI, ESPN, Rivals (4th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Jackson, Marlin |
DB |
2004 |
No |
|
AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, ESPN |
Edwards, Braylon |
WR |
2004 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com |
Baas, David |
C |
2004 |
No |
|
AP, FWAA, WC, CBS |
Shazor, Ernest |
DB |
2004 |
No |
|
AP, FWAA, WC, SI, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com |
Hart, Mike |
RB |
2006 |
No |
No |
CFN, Rivals.com |
Branch, Alan |
DT |
2006 |
No |
|
SI, PFW, ESPN, Scout.com |
Woodley, LaMarr |
LB |
2006 |
No |
Yes |
AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, TSN, ESPN, CBS, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
Hall, Leon |
DB |
2006 |
No |
Yes |
AP, FWAA, AFCA, WC, PFW, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
Long, Jake |
OT |
2006 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
Long, Jake |
OT |
2007 |
Yes |
Yes |
AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, TSN, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
Graham, Brandon |
DE |
2009 |
No |
No |
ESPN, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
Robinson, Denard |
QB |
2010 |
No |
No |
FWAA (6th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
Molk, David |
C |
2011 |
No |
Yes |
AP, AFCA, FWAA, SI |
Lewan, Taylor |
OT |
2012 |
No |
No |
WC, ESPN, AP, SI |