Championships and Accomplishments
- American Championship Entertainment
- ACE Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Mo Sexton
- American Wrestling Alliance
- AWA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- AWA Lightweight Championship (1 time)
- AWA Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Rob Vegas
- Big Time Wrestling
- BTW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- Family Wrestling Entertainment
- FWE Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- FWE Tri-Borough Championship (1 time)
- FWE Rumble (2012)
- International High Powered Wrestling
- IHPW Diamond Division Championship (1 time)
- IHPW United States Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- Jersey All Pro Wrestling
- JAPW Heavyweight Championship (2 times)
- JAPW Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- JAPW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Azrieal
- JAPW Television Championship (1 time)
- Jersey City Rumble (2009)
- Jersey Championship Wrestling
- JCW Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- JCW Television Championship (1 time)
- Jersey J-Cup (2003)
- Millennium Wrestling Federation
- MWF Television Championship (1 time)
- National Wrestling Superstars
- WSU/NWS King and Queen Tournament (2009) – with Miss April
- Politically Incorrect Wrestling
- PIW World Championship (1 time)
- Pro-Wrestling ELITE
- PWE Interstate Championship (1 time)
- Pro Wrestling Illustrated
- PWI ranked him #27 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2008
- Ring of Honor
- ROH Pure Championship (1 time)
- ROH World Television Championship (1 time)
- Honor Rumble (2011)
- Survival of the Fittest (2012)
- Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
- TNA World Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Consequences Creed
- TNA X Division Championship (6 times)
- World X Cup (2006) – with Chris Sabin, Sonjay Dutt and Alex Shelley
- X Division Wrestler of the Year (2007)
- United Wrestling Coalition
- UWC United States Championship (1 time)
- Unreal Championship Wrestling
- UCW United States Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- UCW World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards
- Worst Worked Match of the Year (2006)
Read more about this topic: Jay Lethal