1990s
- 1990 (17th) - Henry Darrow as Rafael Castillo, Santa Barbara
- Roscoe Born as Robert Barr, Santa Barbara
- Robert Gentry as Ross Chandler, All My Children
- Quinn Redeker as Rex Sterling, The Young and the Restless
- Kin Shriner as Scott Baldwin, General Hospital
- Kristoff St. John as Adam Marshall, Generations
- Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
- 1991 (18th) - Bernie Barrow as Louie Slavinski, Loving
- William Christian as Derek Frye, All My Children
- Stuart Damon as Alan Quartermaine, General Hospital
- William Roerick as Henry Chamberlain, Guiding Light
- Kin Shriner as Scott Baldwin, General Hospital
- Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
- 1992 (19th) - Thom Christopher as Carlo Hesser, One Life to Live
- Bernie Barrow as Louie Slavinski, Loving
- Rick Hearst as Alan-Michael Spaulding, Guiding Light
- Charles Keating as Carl Hutchins, Another World
- Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
- 1993 (20th) - Gerald Anthony as Marco Dane, General Hospital
- Thom Christopher as Mortimer Bern, One Life to Live
- Rick Hearst as Alan-Michael Spaulding, Guiding Light
- Charles Keating as Carl Hutchins, Another World
- Kin Shriner as Scott Baldwin, General Hospital
- 1994 (21st) - Justin Deas as Buzz Cooper, Guiding Light
- Ian Buchanan as James Warwick, The Bold and the Beautiful
- Thom Christopher as Mortimer Bern, One Life to Live
- Patrick Tovatt as Cal Stricklyn, As the World Turns
- Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
- 1995 (22nd) - Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
- Keith Hamilton Cobb as Noah Keefer, All My Children
- Ian Buchanan as James Warwick, The Bold and the Beautiful
- Rick Hearst as Alan-Michael Spaulding, Guiding Light
- Roger Howarth as Todd Manning, One Life to Live
- 1996 (23rd) - Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
- Frank Beaty as Brent Lawrence, Guiding Light
- Ian Buchanan as James Warwick,The Bold and the Beautiful
- Stuart Damon as Alan Quartermaine, General Hospital
- David Forsyth as John Hudson, Another World
- Michael Sutton as Stone Cates, General Hospital
- 1997 (24th) - Ian Buchanan as James Warwick, The Bold and the Beautiful
- Maurice Benard as Sonny Corinthos, General Hospital
- Stuart Damon as Alan Quartermaine, General Hospital
- Brad Maule as Tony Jones, General Hospital
- Aaron Lustig as Tim Reid, The Young and the Restless
- Scott Reeves as Ryan McNeil, The Young and the Restless
- 1998 (25th) - Steve Burton as Jason Morgan, General Hospital
- Grant Aleksander as Phillip Spaulding, Guiding Light
- Ian Buchanan as James Warwick, The Bold and the Beautiful
- Michael E. Knight as Tad Martin, All My Children
- Scott Reeves as Ryan McNeil, The Young and the Restless
- 1999 (26th) - Stuart Damon as Alan Quartermaine, General Hospital
- Michael E. Knight as Tad Martin, All My Children
- Christian LeBlanc as Michael Baldwin, The Young and the Restless
- Kristoff St. John as Neil Winters, The Young and the Restless
- Jerry verDorn as Ross Marler, Guiding Light
Read more about this topic: Daytime Emmy Award For Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Drama Series