Christmas Eve and Other Stories - Track Listing

Track Listing

1. "An Angel Came Down" (Franz Gruber, O'Neill, Oliva) – 3:52
2. "O Come All Ye Faithful/O Holy Night" (Wade, Oakeley, Reading, Adam, Dwight, O'Neill, Kinkel) – 4:19 *
3. "A Star to Follow" (O'Neill) – 3:49
4. "First Snow" (O'Neill) – 3:53 *
5. "The Silent Nutcracker" (O'Neill) – 2:22 *
6. "A Mad Russian's Christmas" (Tchaikovsky, Kinkel, Oliva) – 4:42 *
7. "The Prince of Peace" (Mendelssohn, Wesley, O'Neill) – 3:33
8. "Christmas Eve/Sarajevo 12/24" (O'Neill, Kinkel, Oliva) – 3:25 *
9. "Good King Joy" (Lowell Mason, Kinkel, O'Neill) – 6:36
10. "Ornament" (O'Neill, Oliva) – 3:37
11. "The First Noel" (O'Neill) – 0:55 *
12. "Old City Bar" (O'Neill) – 6:18
13. "Promises to Keep" (O'Neill, Kinkel, Oliva) – 2:41
14. "This Christmas Day" (O'Neill, Oliva) – 4:20
15. "An Angel Returned" (O'Neill, Oliva) – 3:52
16. "O Holy Night" (Adam, Dwight) – 2:39 *
17. "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" (Traditional) – 1:16 *

• (*) indicates an instrumental

• "Christmas Eve/Sarajevo 12/24" is performed by Savatage and was first released on the Savatage album Dead Winter Dead in 1995.

• Songs "O Holy Night" and "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" are bonus tracks.

There is a 2 CD version of Christmas Eve and Other Stories with one CD containing a Special Narrated Version Of Christmas Eve and Other Stories. The narrated CD contains one continuous track of music, with narration by Russell Horton between songs. This special edit was done by Robert Kinkel and was produced by Taro Meyer.

In 2001, the Target retail chain in the United States issued a version of the album with a different catalog number and a sticker attached to the front shrink wrap stating "Target Exclusive: 2 Bonus Songs Included." The two tracks are not identified on the cover or any of the album packaging, but they are as follows:

1. "Whoville Medley (Perfect Christmas Night/Grinch)" - 2:38, which originally appeared on the 2000 soundtrack album to the movie Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas
2. "The World That He Sees" - 4:43, which was added to The Christmas Attic album sometime after its release; it does not appear on original 1998 editions of the CD.

They are located after the two "official" bonus tracks on the original CD.

Some other post-2000 copies of the CD contain "Whoville Medley (Perfect Christmas Night/Grinch)" as an unlisted 18th track, without "The World That He Sees."