Year-by-year
| Year | Division | Team name | League | Regular season | Playoffs | Nationals venue | Nationals |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | n/a | ||||||
| 2002 | Senior amateur | Breakers | PEI Challenge Cup | 2nd | Runner-up | St. John's, NL | n/a |
| 2003 | Senior amateur | Breakers | PEI Challenge Cup | 1st | Champions | Quebec City, QC | 8th |
| 2004 | Senior amateur | Velvet Underground FC | PEI Challenge Cup | 1st | Champions | Charlottetown, PE | 7th |
| 2005 | Senior amateur | Velvet Underground FC | PEI Challenge Cup | 2nd | Runner-up | Calgary, AB | n/a |
| 2006 | Senior amateur | Velvet Underground FC | PEI Challenge Cup | 1st | Champions | Surrey, BC | 5th |
| 2007 | Senior amateur | Velvet Underground FC | NSSL | 3rd | n/a | Halifax, NS | 9th |
| 2008 | Senior amateur | Avondale Islanders | NSSL | 4th | n/a | St. John's, NL | Bronze |
| 2009 | Senior amateur | Avondale Islanders | MSSL | 1st | n/a | Saskatoon, SK | Bronze |
| 2010 | Senior amateur | Churchill Arms FC | PEI Challenge Cup | 1st | Champions | Charlottetown, PE | Gold |
| 2011 | Senior amateur | Soccerstop Edge FC | PEI Challenge Cup | 1st | Champions | Brossard, Qc | 8th |
| 2012 | Senior amateur | PEI FC | PEI Challenge Cup/NBPSL | 1st | Champions | 4th |
|}
Read more about this topic: Avondale Islanders