- 1960
- Jimmie Coker, C, Philadelphia Phillies
- Jim Gentile, 1B, Baltimore Orioles
- Julián Javier, 2B, St. Louis Cardinals
- Ron Santo, 3B, Chicago Cubs †
- Ron Hansen, SS, Baltimore Orioles
- Tony Curry, OF, Philadelphia Phillies
- Tommy Davis, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers
- Frank Howard, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers
- Chuck Estrada, RHP, Baltimore Orioles
- Dick Stigman, LHP, Cleveland Indians
- 1961
- Joe Torre, C, Milwaukee Braves
- J. C. Martin, 1B, Chicago White Sox
- Jake Wood, 2B, Detroit Tigers
- Charley Smith, 3B, Chicago White Sox
- Dick Howser, SS, Kansas City Athletics
- Floyd Robinson, OF, Chicago White Sox
- Lee Thomas, OF, Los Angeles Angels
- Billy Williams, OF, Chicago Cubs †
- Don Schwall, RHP, Boston Red Sox
- Jack Curtis, LHP, Chicago Cubs
- 1962
- Bob Rodgers, C, Los Angeles Angels
- Fred Whitfield, 1B, Cleveland Indians
- Bernie Allen, 2B, Minnesota Twins
- Ed Charles, 3B, Kansas City Athletics
- Tom Tresh, SS, New York Yankees
- Manny Jiminez, OF, Kansas City Athletics
- Al Luplow, OF, Cleveland Indians
- Boog Powell, OF, Baltimore Orioles
- Dean Chance, RHP, Los Angeles Angels
- Al Jackson, LHP, New York Mets
- 1963
- Jesse Gonder, C, New York Mets
- Rusty Staub, 1B, Houston Colt .45's
- Pete Rose, 2B, Cincinnati Reds
- Pete Ward, 3B, Chicago White Sox
- Al Weis, SS, Chicago White Sox
- Vic Davalillo, OF, Cleveland Indians
- Jimmie Hall, OF, Minnesota Twins
- Tommy Harper, OF, Cincinnati Reds
- Ray Culp, RHP, Philadelphia Phillies
- Gary Peters, LHP, Chicago White Sox
- 1964
- Mike Brumley, C, Washington Senators
- Bob Chance, 1B, Washington Senators
- Hal Lanier, 2B, San Francisco Giants
- Richie Allen, 3B, Philadelphia Phillies
- Bert Campaneris, SS, Kansas City Athletics
- Rico Carty, OF, Milwaukee Braves
- Tony Conigliaro, OF, Boston Red Sox
- Tony Oliva, OF, Minnesota Twins
- Wally Bunker, RHP, Baltimore Orioles
- Bill McCool, LHP, Cincinnati Reds
|
- 1965
- Pat Corrales, C, St. Louis Cardinals
- Tony Pérez, 1B, Cincinnati Reds †
- Joe Morgan, 2B, Houston Astros †
- Paul Schaal, 3B, California Angels
- Rico Petrocelli, SS, Boston Red Sox
- Curt Blefary, OF, Baltimore Orioles
- José Cardenal, OF, California Angels
- Ron Swoboda, OF, New York Mets
- Frank Linzy, RHP, San Francisco Giants
- Marcelino López, LHP, California Angels
- 1966
- Randy Hundley, C, Chicago Cubs
- George Scott, 1B, Boston Red Sox
- Davey Johnson, 2B, Baltimore Orioles
- Tommy Helms, 3B, Cincinnati Reds
- Sonny Jackson, SS, Houston Astros
- Tommie Agee, OF, Chicago White Sox
- Byron Browne, OF, Chicago Cubs
- Cleon Jones, OF, New York Mets
- Jim Nash, RHP, Kansas City Athletics
- Woodie Fryman, LHP, Pittsburgh Pirates
- 1967
- Dick Dietz, C, San Francisco Giants
- Lee May, 1B, Cincinnati Reds
- Rod Carew, 2B, Minnesota Twins †
- Bobby Etheridge, 3B, San Francisco Giants
- Tim Cullen, SS, Washington Senators
- Rick Monday, OF, Oakland Athletics
- Reggie Smith, OF, Boston Red Sox
- Walt Williams, OF Chicago White Sox
- Dick Hughes, RHP, St. Louis Cardinals
- Tom Seaver, RHP, New York Mets †
- Rich Nye, LHP, Chicago Cubs
- 1968
- Johnny Bench, C, Cincinnati Reds †
- Gary Holman, 1B, Washington Senators
- Dave Nelson, 2B, Cleveland Indians
- Ken Boswell, 2B, New York Mets
- Bobby Cox, 3B, New York Yankees
- Héctor Torres, SS, Houston Astros
- Bobby Bonds, OF, San Francisco Giants
- Dave Marshall, OF, San Francisco Giants
- Del Unser, OF, Washington Senators
- Stan Bahnsen, RHP, New York Yankees
- Jerry Koosman, LHP, New York Mets
- 1969
- Bob Didier, C, Atlanta Braves
- Al Oliver, 1B, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Ted Sizemore, 2B, Los Angeles Dodgers
- Coco Laboy, 3B, Montreal Expos
- Don Money, SS, Philadelphia Phillies
- Larry Hisle, OF, Philadelphia Phillies
- Carlos May, OF, Chicago White Sox
- Lou Piniella, OF, Kansas City Royals
- Mike Nagy, RHP, Boston Red Sox
- Bill Butler, LHP, Kansas City Royals
|