| Name | Tool Name | Girlfriend | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Josh (Joshua) Douglas | Tiny Tool | Ashley Pellegrino | Winner in final episode |
| Matsuflex (Ryan Matsunaga) | Naked Tool | Jenna | Runner Up in final episode |
| Shawn | Loud Mouth Tool | Aida | Eliminated in episode 7 |
| Tommy Houlihan | Slacker Tool | Krista Grubb | Eliminated in episode 6 |
| Rob (Robert) | Power Tool | Karine | Withdrew in episode 5 |
| M.E.G.A. (Joshua) | Playa Pimpin' Tool | Margo | Eliminated in episode 4 |
| Celebrity (Clarence) | Party Tool | Cameron | Eliminated in episode 3 |
| Joey | Cold-Hearted Tool | Ashley | Eliminated in episode 2 |
| Dimitri | Greek Tool | Jill | Eliminated in episode 1 |
- ^ Shawn started the show with Jaimee Grubbs as his girlfriend. However, on episode 2, she was replaced by Aida, his girlfriend of the past six years.
- ^ Rob withdrew from the competition after being medically treated for anxiety over the lie detector challenge.
Read more about this topic: Tool Academy (season 1)