- 1960: Michael Kidd – Destry Rides Again
- Peter Gennaro – Fiorello!
- Joe Layton – Greenwillow
- Lee Scot – Happy Town
- Onna White – Take Me Along
- 1961: Gower Champion – Bye Bye Birdie
- Onna White – Irma La Douce
- 1962: Joe Layton – No Strings
- Agnes de Mille – Kwamina
- Michael Kidd – Subways Are For Sleeping
- Dania Krupska – The Happiest Girl in the World
- 1963: Bob Fosse – Little Me
- Carol Haney – Bravo Giovanni
- 1964: Gower Champion – Hello, Dolly!
- Danny Daniels – High Spirits
- Carol Haney – Funny Girl
- Herbert Ross – Anyone Can Whistle
- 1965: Jerome Robbins – Fiddler on the Roof
- Peter Gennaro – Bajour
- Donald McKayle – Golden Boy
- Onna White – Half a Sixpence
|
- 1966: Bob Fosse – Sweet Charity
- Jack Cole – Man of La Mancha
- Michael Kidd – Skyscraper
- Onna White – Mame
- 1967: Ron Field – Cabaret
- Michael Bennett – A Joyful Noise
- Danny Daniels – Walking Happy and Annie Get Your Gun
- Lee Theodore – The Apple Tree
- 1968: Gower Champion – The Happy Time
- Michael Bennett – Henry, Sweet Henry
- Kevin Carlisle – Hallelujah, Baby!
- Onna White – Illya Darling
- 1969: Joe Layton – George M!
- Sammy Bayes – Canterbury Tales
- Ronald Field – Zorba
- Michael Bennett – Promises, Promises
|