Playoffs
- 2002 DNQ
- 2003 Lost Semi-final
- Thunder Bay Bulldogs defeated Fort William Wolves 4-games-to-1
- 2004 Won League, Lost Dudley Hewitt Cup semi-final
- Fort William North Stars defeated Thunder Bay Bulldogs 4-games-to-none
- Fort William North Stars defeated Dryden Ice Dogs 4-games-to-1 SIJHL CHAMPIONS
- Second in Dudley Hewitt Cup round robin (1-2)
- North Bay Skyhawks (NOJHL) defeated Fort William North Stars 3-2 in semi-final
- 2005 Won League, Lost Dudley Hewitt Cup semi-final
- Fort William North Stars defeated K&A First Nations Golden Hawks 4-games-to-none
- Fort William North Stars defeated Fort Frances Borderland Thunder 4-games-to-none SIJHL CHAMPIONS
- Second in Dudley Hewitt Cup round robin (2-1)
- St. Michael's Buzzers (OPJHL) defeated Fort William North Stars 6-2 in semi-final
- 2006 Won League, Won Dudley Hewitt Cup, Lost 2006 Royal Bank Cup semi-final
- Fort William North Stars defeated K&A First Nations Golden Hawks 4-games-to-none
- Fort William North Stars defeated Dryden Ice Dogs 4-games-to-none SIJHL CHAMPIONS
- First in Dudley Hewitt Cup round robin (2-1)
- Fort William North Stars defeated Sudbury Jr. Wolves (NOJHL) 7-6 OT in final DUDLEY HEWITT CUP CHAMPIONS
- Third in 2006 Royal Bank Cup round robin (2-2)
- Burnaby Express (BCHL) defeated Fort William North Stars 3-2 OT in semi-final
- 2007 Lost Final
- Fort William North Stars defeated Dryden Ice Dogs 4-games-to-1
- Schreiber Diesels defeated Fort William North Stars 4-games-to-3
- 2008 Lost Final
- Fort William North Stars defeated Thunder Bay Bearcats 4-games-to-1
- Dryden Ice Dogs defeated Fort William North Stars 4-games-to-1
- 2009 Won League, Lost Dudley Hewitt Cup final
- Fort William North Stars defeated Schreiber Diesels 4-games-to-3
- Fort William North Stars defeated Thunder Bay Bearcats 4-games-to-1 SIJHL CHAMPIONS
- Second in Dudley Hewitt Cup round robin (2-1)
- Fort William North Stars defeated Schreiber Diesels 4-3 in semi-final
- Kingston Voyageurs (OJHL) defeated Fort William North Stars 4-1 in final
- 2010 Won League, Lost Dudley Hewitt Cup final
- Second in round robin (2-0-2) vs. Dryden Ice Dogs and Sioux Lookout Flyers
- Fort William North Stars defeated Sioux Lookout Flyers 4-games-to-none
- Fort William North Stars defeated Dryden Ice Dogs 4-games-to-1 SIJHL CHAMPIONS
- Second in Dudley Hewitt Cup round robin (1-0-2)
- Fort William North Stars defeated Soo Thunderbirds (NOJHL) 3-0 in semi-final
- Oakville Blades (OJAHL) defeated Fort William North Stars 2-1 in final
- 2011 Lost Semi-final
- Thunder Bay North Stars defeated Sioux Lookout Flyers 4-games-to-1
- Wisconsin Wilderness defeated Thunder Bay North Stars 4-games-to-none
- 2012 Lost Semi-final
- Thunder Bay North Stars defeated Duluth Clydesdales 4-games-to-none
- Wisconsin Wilderness defeated Thunder Bay North Stars 4-games-to-none
- 2013 Lost Quarter-final
- Minnesota Iron Rangers defeated Thunder Bay North Stars 2-games-to-1
Read more about this topic: Thunder Bay North Stars, Season-by-season Results