Playoffs
- 2002 Lost Semi-final
- Dryden Ice Dogs defeated Nipigon Featherman Hawks 4-games-to-none
- 2003 DNQ
- 2004 DNQ
- 2005 Lost Semi-final
- Fort William North Stars defeated K&A Golden Hawks 4-games-to-none
- 2006 Lost Semi-final
- Fort William North Stars defeated K&A Golden Hawks 4-games-to-none
- 2007 Lost Semi-final
- Schreiber Diesels defeated Thunder Bay Bearcats 4-games-to-2
- 2008 Lost Semi-final
- Thunder Bay Bearcats defeated Thunder Bay Bulldogs 3-games-to-none
- Fort William North Stars defeated Thunder Bay Bearcats 4-games-to-1
- 2009 Lost Final
- Thunder Bay Bearcats defeated Fort Frances Jr. Sabres 4-games-to-1
- Fort William North Stars defeated Thunder Bay Bearcats 4-games-to-1
Read more about this topic: Thunder Bay Bearcats, Season-by-Season Results