- 1960
- Ron Hansen (Baltimore AL, SS)
- Frank Howard (Los Angeles NL, OF)
- 1961
- Dick Howser (Kansas City AL, SS)
- Don Schwall (Boston AL, P)
- Ken Hunt (Cincinnati NL, P)
- Billy Williams (Chicago NL, OF)
- 1962
- Tom Tresh (New York AL, OF-SS)
- Ken Hubbs (Chicago NL, 2B)
- 1963
- Gary Peters (Chicago AL, P)
- Pete Ward (Chicago AL, 3B)
- Ray Culp (Philadelphia NL, P)
- Pete Rose (Cincinnati NL, 2B)
- 1964
- Wally Bunker (Baltimore AL, P)
- Tony Oliva (Minnesota AL, OF)
- Billy McCool (Cincinnati NL, P)
- Dick Allen (Philadelphia NL, 3B)
|
- 1965
- Marcelino López (California AL, P)
- Curt Blefary (Baltimore AL, OF)
- Frank Linzy (San Francisco NL, P)
- Joe Morgan (Houston NL, 2B)
- 1966
- Jim Nash (Kansas City AL, P)
- Tommie Agee (Chicago AL, OF)
- Don Sutton (Los Angeles NL, P)
- Tommy Helms (Cincinnati NL, 3B)
- 1967
- Tom Phoebus (Baltimore AL, P)
- Rod Carew (Minnesota AL, 2B)
- Dick Hughes (St. Louis NL, P)
- Lee May (Cincinnati NL, 1B)
- 1968
- Stan Bahnsen (New York AL, P)
- Del Unser (Washington AL, OF)
- Jerry Koosman (New York NL, P)
- Johnny Bench (Cincinnati NL, C)
- 1969
- Mike Nagy (Boston AL, P)
- Carlos May (Chicago AL, OF)
- Tom Griffin (Houston NL, P)
- Coco Laboy (Montreal NL, 2B)
|