- 1950
- Whitey Ford (New York AL, P)
- 1951
- Minnie Miñoso (Chicago AL, OF)
- Willie Mays (New York NL, OF)
- 1952
- Clint Courtney (St. Louis AL, C)
- Joe Black (Brooklyn NL, P)
- 1953
- Harvey Kuenn (Detroit AL, SS)
- Jim Gilliam (Brooklyn NL, 2B)
- 1954
- Bob Grim (New York AL, P)
- Wally Moon (St. Louis NL, OF)
|
- 1955
- Herb Score (Cleveland AL, P)
- Bill Virdon (St. Louis NL, OF)
- 1956
- Luis Aparicio (Chicago AL, SS)
- Frank Robinson (Cincinnati NL, OF)
- 1957
- Tony Kubek (New York AL, IF-OF)
- Ed Bouchee (Philadelphia AL, 1B)
- Jack Sanford (Philadelphia NL, P)
- 1958
- Ryne Duren (New York AL, P)
- Albie Pearson (Washington AL, OF)
- Orlando Cepeda (San Francisco NL, 1B)
- Carlton Willey (Milwaukee NL, P)
- 1959
- Bob Allison (Washington AL, OF)
- Willie McCovey (San Francisco NL, 1B)
|