Finals
| Date | Winner | Scorers | Runner-up | Scorers | Score | Venue | Attendance | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 August 2002 | AFC Wimbledon | Sheerin, Cooper, Sidwell | Enfield Town | Alleyne, St Hilaire | 3–2 | Cheshunt Stadium | 521 | |
| 2003 | Not Held | |||||||
| 20 July 2004 | Brentford | Burton, Peters | AFC Wimbledon | – | 2–0 | Griffin Park | 2,562 | |
| 23 July 2005 | AFC Wimbledon | Crace | FC United | – | 1–0 | Kingsmeadow | 3,301 | |
| 22 July 2006 | FC United | Brown, Torpey | AFC Wimbledon | Barnes | 2–1 | Gigg Lane | 2,136 | |
| 4 August 2007 | Enfield Town | Edmunds | Cambridge City | Midgley | 1–1 | Goldsdown Road | 244 | |
| 19 July 2008 | Brentford | Connell, Elder | AFC Wimbledon | Main | 2–1 | Kingsmeadow | 1,361 | |
| 25 July 2009 | AFC Wimbledon | Judge, Rapson | FC United | – | 2–0 | Kingsmeadow | 1,772 | |
| 24 July 2010 | AFC Telford | Brown, Meechan | FC United | – | 2–0 | New Bucks Head | 803 | |
| 16 July 2011 | Chester | Ormrod, Brown | FC United | Neville | 2–1 | Deva Stadium | 1,927 | |
| 8 July 2012 | Enfield Town | Kirby, Hope (2) | Wrexham | Salathiel | 3–1 | Queen Elizabeth Stadium | 306 | |
Read more about this topic: Supporters Direct, Competitions, Supporters Direct Cup