The event took place on December 12, 2011 in Norfolk, Virginia.
| Poll |
Presenter(s) |
Results |
| Outstanding Achievement in Muppet Resemblance |
WWE.com |
- Sheamus and his long lost, red-headed cousin Beaker
|
| The Pee-wee Herman Bowtie Award |
WWE.com |
- David Otunga, for his Harvard-law-by-way-of-the-Playhouse business attire
|
| Most Predictable Outcome of the Year |
WWE.com |
- Kevin Nash's powerbomb to Santino Marella after the trombone dance
|
| Guess Who's Back or: Return of the Year |
WWE.com |
|
| Double Vision Moment of the Year |
WWE.com |
|
| T-Shirt of the Year |
WWE.com |
- CM Punk for "Best in the World" T-shirt
|
| WWE.com Exclusive of the Year |
WWE.com |
- John Laurinaitis congratulates CM Punk
|
| Most Regrettable Attire of the Year |
WWE.com |
|
| Critter Moment of the Year |
WWE.com |
- The mouse that ran past Alberto Del Rio on Raw
|
| Superstar Transformation of the Year |
WWE.com |
|
"Tell Me I Did NOT Just See That"
Moment of the Year |
Booker T and Hornswoggle |
- Jim Ross dancing during the "Michael Cole Challenge" on Raw Supershow
- Santino Marella almost winning the 2011 Royal Rumble
- The Miz disguised as The Rock
- A young fan splashes water into R-Truth's face
|
| Holy $#!+ Move of the Year |
Mick Foley and Ted DiBiase |
- Big Show and Mark Henry implode the ring after a superplex at Vengeance
- Sheamus delivers a powerbomb to Sin Cara through a ladder at Money in the Bank
- Evan Bourne performs an Air Bourne off a ladder at Money in the Bank
- Randy Orton RKO's Christian onto the steel steps at SummerSlam
|
| "Pipe Bomb" of the Year |
Road Dogg |
|
| Divalicious Moment of the Year |
Lita |
- Kelly Kelly wins the WWE Divas Championship
- Natalya puts Layla and Eve Torres in a double sharpshooter
- Kharma debuts at Extreme Rules
- Beth Phoenix gives Eve Torres a Glam Slam from the top rope at Survivor Series
|
| OMG Moment of the Year |
Santino Marella and The Bella Twins |
- Triple H performs The Undertaker's Tombstone Piledriver on The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXVII
- The Rock gives John Cena a Rock Bottom at WrestleMania XXVII
- WWE Superstars vote of no confidence and walkout on Triple H
- CM Punk wins the WWE Championship at Money in the Bank and walks away from WWE
|
| #Trending Superstar of the Year |
David Otunga and Tony Atlas |
- Zack Ryder
- Dolph Ziggler
- Cody Rhodes
- Daniel Bryan
|
| Game Changer of the Year |
Christian |
- John Cena vs. The Rock at WrestleMania XXVIII
- Vince McMahon removed from WWE
- Edge retires
- Kevin Nash returns at SummerSlam
|
| WWE A-lister of the Year |
Vickie Guerrero and Goldust |
- Nicole "Snooki" Polizzi
- The Muppets
- Hugh Jackman
- Cee Lo Green
|
| Superstar of the Year |
Rey Mysterio |
- CM Punk
- John Cena
- Randy Orton
- Mark Henry
- Alberto Del Rio
- The Miz
|