Problems With The Pointer Machine Model
Use of the model in complexity theory: van Emde Boas (1990) expresses concern that this form of abstract model is:
- "an interesting theoretical model, but ... its attractiveness as a fundamental model for complexity theory is questionable. Its time measure is based on uniform time in a context where this measure is known to underestimate the true time complexity. The same observation holds for the space measure for the machine" (van Emde Boas (1990) p. 35)
Gurevich 1988 also expresses concern:
- "Pragmatically speaking, the Schönhage model provides a good measure of time complexity at the current state of the art (though I would prefer something along the lines of the random access computers of Angluin and Valiant)" (Gurevich (1988) p. 6 with reference to Angluin D. and Valiant L. G., Fast Probabilistic Algorithms for Hamiltonian Circuits and Matchings", Journal of Computer and System Sciences 18 (1979) 155-193.)
The fact that, in §3 and §4 (pp. 494–497), Schönhage himself (1980) demonstrates the real-time equivalences of his two Random Access Machine models "RAM0" and "RAM1" leads one to question the necessity of the SMM for complexity studies.
Potential uses for the model: However, Schönhage (1980) demonstrates in his §6, Integer-multiplication in linear time. And Gurevich wonders whether or not the "parallel KU machine" "resembles somewhat the human brain" (Gurevich (1988) p. 5)
Read more about this topic: Pointer Machine
Famous quotes containing the words problems with, problems, pointer, machine and/or model:
“I was a wonderful parent before I had children. I was an expert on why everyone else was having problems with theirs. Then I had three of my own.”
—Adele Faber (20th century)
“As our disorderly, competitive technological society is piling up its victims and constantly developing new problems of maladjustment, we must use our scientific knowledge to determine the cause and prevention of suffering rather than putting all our emphasis on its alleviation ...”
—Agnes E. Meyer (1887–1970)
“The hardiest skeptic who has seen a horse broken, a pointer trained, or has visited a menagerie or the exhibition of the Industrious Fleas, will not deny the validity of education. “A boy,” says Plato, “is the most vicious of all beasts;” and in the same spirit the old English poet Gascoigne says, “A boy is better unborn than untaught.””
—Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803–1882)
“A multitude of little superfluous precautions engender here a population of deputies and sub-officials, each of whom acquits himself with an air of importance and a rigorous precision, which seemed to say, though everything is done with much silence, “Make way, I am one of the members of the grand machine of state.””
—Marquis De Custine (1790–1857)
“The striking point about our model family is not simply the compete-compete, consume-consume style of life it urges us to follow.... The striking point, in the face of all the propaganda, is how few Americans actually live this way.”
—Louise Kapp Howe (b. 1934)