Perforce - Concurrency Model

Concurrency Model

The Perforce system offers a hybrid of merge and lock concurrency models. As with similar systems, users do not have to lock files in order to work on them and are required to resolve concurrent, committed changes before submitting their work. Users may optionally lock files to ensure that they won't have to resolve concurrent changes.

However, the Perforce model is slightly different from those of similar systems in that users are expected to let the system know in advance which files they intend to change, even if they don't mean to lock them. Giving advance notice puts files in a pending changelist that can be submitted to the server. It also enables the system to alert other users working on the same files. Thus users can tell when they are working in parallel and can take the opportunity to coordinate with one another before making changes that could otherwise be difficult to merge.

Perforce enforces this advanced notification requirement loosely by setting read-only permission on workspace files as it fetches them from the repository. Users can bypass the requirement, by choice or by necessity (when working offline, for example), simply by hijacking file permissions and modifying files as they see fit. It is up to the user, in these cases, to remember to use Perforce to reconcile offline work and put hijacked files in a pending changelist so they can be submitted. (It is also up to users to leave hijacked files writable after changing them. A read-only file that is not in a pending changelist is assumed by Perforce to be a candidate for update by replacement.)