O'Donnabhain V. Commissioner - Arguments


26 U.S.C. § 213 allows taxpayers to deduct medical expenses, but not cosmetic surgery, which it defines as "any procedure which is directed at improving the patient’s appearance and does not meaningfully promote the proper function of the body or prevent or treat illness or disease."

O'Donnabhain argued that her surgery was "medically necessary and directed toward the cure, mitigation and treatment of Ms. O’Donnabhain’s diagnosed gender identity disorder."

The IRS issued a memorandum stating that:

Whether gender reassignment surgery is a treatment for an illness or disease is controversial. For instance, Johns Hopkins Hospital has closed its gender reassignment clinic and ceased performing these operations.... In light of the Congressional emphasis on denying a deduction for procedures relating to appearance in all but a few circumstances and the controversy surrounding whether GRS is a treatment for an illness or disease, the materials submitted do not support a deduction.

In the clearest possible statement the US Tax Court declared "In its decision yesterday, the tax court said the IRS position was “at best a superficial characterization of the circumstances” that is “thoroughly rebutted by the medical evidence.”" The IRS case was based on unverified studies by Johns Hopkins' Paul McHugh, who worked for the Catholic Church. McHugh declared even before taking over the Johns Hopkins that it was his intention to close out any department that had anything to do with gender reassignment. He ordered a study of what he could find of the 24 women the unit had treated. Of 2,000 applications made by reassignment only 24 were chosen and they were chosen entirely for looks. Many questions remain about the religious bias of the IRS, as the results of the follow-up study were published in a Catholic journal the IRS would later use to close out deductions for surgery.

Read more about this topic:  O'Donnabhain V. Commissioner

Other articles related to "arguments":

Sass (stylesheet Language) - Mixins - Arguments
... Mixins also support arguments ... @mixin left($dist) { float left margin-left $dist } #data { @include left(10px) } Would compile to #data { float left margin-left 10px } ...
List Of Big Brother 2004 Housemates (UK) - Victor
... He had numerous arguments with Housemate Emma, with the two having to be separated by Big Brother at one point ... Emma and Victor would later engage in numerous arguments both inside and out of the house ... Victor received his first official strike on Day 21, following numerous arguments and physical violence amongst the group ...
Stettinius V. United States
... right of defendant in criminal case not to have judge render decision on motions until all arguments made, to defer making those arguments until the jury ...
List Of Big Brother 2004 Housemates (UK) - Emma
... She engaged in numerous arguments during her stay in the house, most notably with Housemates Kitten and Victor ... Emma and Victor would later engage in numerous arguments both inside and out of the house ... Their return later caused a string of highly controversial arguments between numerous Housemates, with Emma being a part of numerous arguments that night ...
Create Debate - Functionality
... structure that lets people see what the most convincing arguments are within each debate, and which side of a debate has the most popular support ... The CreateDebate community then votes the arguments "up" or "down" ... Over time, the most convincing arguments rise to the top of the debate, which distills out the central points and most relevant factors ...

Famous quotes containing the word arguments:

    Argument is conclusive ... but ... it does not remove doubt, so that the mind may rest in the sure knowledge of the truth, unless it finds it by the method of experiment.... For if any man who never saw fire proved by satisfactory arguments that fire burns ... his hearer’s mind would never be satisfied, nor would he avoid the fire until he put his hand in it ... that he might learn by experiment what argument taught.
    Roger Bacon (c. 1214–1294)

    We are seeing an increasing level of attacks on the “selfishness” of women. There are allegations that all kinds of social ills, from runaway children to the neglected elderly, are due to the fact that women have left their “rightful” place in the home. Such arguments are simplistic and wrongheaded but women are especially vulnerable to the accusation that if society has problems, it’s because women aren’t nurturing enough.
    Grace Baruch (20th century)

    Yesterday the Electoral Commission decided not to go behind the papers filed with the Vice-President in the case of Florida.... I read the arguments in the Congressional Record and can’t see how lawyers can differ on the question. But the decision is by a strictly party vote—eight Republicans against seven Democrats! It shows the strength of party ties.
    Rutherford Birchard Hayes (1822–1893)